“We must drop the metaphor of a “war on terrorism.” Wars are mostly fought with arms on battlefields between soldiers of opposing countries. Wars have beginnings and ends. None of these characteristics apply here.”
–Richard Haass
Of all the mistakes the Bush Administration has made, their most most historically significant error may have been the elevation of terrorism from the mundane purview of criminal justice to the status of a “war” that requires the engagement of the full force and might of the United States military.
Identifying, tracking and defeating terrorists requires the surgical precision of intelligence operations, not the heavy cudgel of carpet bombs and special forces. We have proof of this now in Iraq. Using the military to fight terrorism only serves to breed more terrorists.
The president’s motives in re-casting the fight against terror as a “war” are clear: He wanted to become, as he put it, “a war president.” During war-time, presidents can claim nearly dictatorial privileges, and war presidents are harder to defeat in elections.
In that sense, the president’s war on terror has been a rousing political success — for President Bush. With the assistance of a pliable Republican Congress and the dimwitted, self-absorbed Washington press corps, he has accrued unprecedented powers for the Executive and won two elections — so far.
But by aggrandizing himself as a warrior president, George Bush also raised the profile of our enemies both as specters of fear for Americans and as heroes among their own people. The moment the president declared his war on terror Osama bin Ladin and his ilk were promoted from the ranks of criminal thugs into a new class of global warriors who became worthy adversaries of the world’s last remaining Superpower.
Richard Haass, the president of the Council on Foreign Relations, and a former high-level State Dept. staffer in the administrations of both Pres. Bush 41 and 43, published an op-ed piece last week calling for an end to the marketing of the fight against terror as “war.” His article is remarkable because it answers the Republicans’ catcall that no one has a better plan than the failed policies of the Bush Administration and the GOP Congress.
If you want solid answers on how to fight the rise in terrorism from the Islamic underground, here is Richard Haass’ plan:
[…]