In Newsweek, Andrew Sullivan Takes on Obama’s Critics on the Right and Left
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Note: The complete transcript of the interview is published below.
Writing in the cover story of the current issue of Newsweek, titled, “Why Are Obama’s Critics So Dumb?” Andrew Sullivan goes after the right wing for its ongoing, deliberate mischaracterizations of the president as a “a radical leftist attempting a ‘fundamental transformation’ of the American way of life.” He writes:
You’d think, listening to the Republican debates, that Obama has raised taxes. Again, this is not true. Not only did he agree not to sunset the Bush tax cuts for his entire first term, he has aggressively lowered taxes on most Americans. A third of the stimulus was tax cuts, affecting 95 percent of taxpayers; he has cut the payroll tax, and recently had to fight to keep it cut against Republican opposition. His spending record is also far better than his predecessor’s. Under Bush, new policies on taxes and spending cost the taxpayer a total of $5.07 trillion. Under Obama’s budgets both past and projected, he will have added $1.4 trillion in two terms. Under Bush and the GOP, nondefense discretionary spending grew by twice as much as under Obama. Again: imagine Bush had been a Democrat and Obama a Republican. You could easily make the case that Obama has been far more fiscally conservative than his predecessor—except, of course, that Obama has had to govern under the worst recession since the 1930s, and Bush, after the 2001 downturn, governed in a period of moderate growth. It takes work to increase the debt in times of growth, as Bush did. It takes much more work to constrain the debt in the deep recession Bush bequeathed Obama.
The great conservative bugaboo, Obamacare, is also far more moderate than its critics have claimed. The Congressional Budget Office has projected it will reduce the deficit, not increase it dramatically, as Bush’s unfunded Medicare Prescription Drug benefit did. It is based on the individual mandate, an idea pioneered by the archconservative Heritage Foundation, Newt Gingrich, and, of course, Mitt Romney, in the past. It does not have a public option; it gives a huge new client base to the drug and insurance companies; its health-insurance exchanges were also pioneered by the right.
But Sullivan, who is a conservative-leaning independent today but was, in the 1990s, as a British citizen living and writing about politics in the United States, a Republican Party sympathizer, also takes on Obama’s critics on the left:
