Why the President’s Stupidity Matters

Jonathan Chait:

[Bush] prefers verbal briefings and often makes a horse-sense judgment based on how confident his briefer seems in what he’s saying.

Ron Suskind’s new book, “The One Percent Doctrine,” paints a harrowing picture of Bush’s intellectual limits. Bush, writes Suskind, “is not much of a reader.” He prefers verbal briefings and often makes a horse-sense judgment based on how confident his briefer seems in what he’s saying. In August 2001, the CIA was in a panic about an upcoming terrorist attack and drafted a report with the title, “Bin Laden Determined to Strike in U.S.” When a CIA staffer summed up the memo’s contents in a face-to-face meeting with Bush, the president found the briefer insufficiently confident and dismissed him by saying, “All right, you’ve covered your ass, now,” according to Suskind. That turned out to be a fairly disastrous judgment.

Bush loyalists like to dismiss Suskind’s reporting, but it jibes with the picture that has emerged from other sources. L. Paul Bremer III’s account of his tenure as head of Iraq’s Coalition Provisional Authority depicts Bush as uninterested in the central questions of rebuilding and occupying the country.

Video of a presidential meeting that came to light this year showed Bush being briefed on the incipient Hurricane Katrina. His subordinates come off as deeply concerned about a potential catastrophe, but Bush appears blase, declining to ask a single question. And of course there was the famous 2001 incident in which Russian President Vladimir Putin conveyed to Bush a story of being given a cross by his mother. Bush invested deep significance in the story. “I found him to be very straightforward and trustworthy,” he told reporters. “I was able to get a sense of his soul.”

Bush’s supporters have insisted for the last six years that liberal derision of the president’s intelligence amounts to nothing more than cultural snobbery. We don’t like his pickup truck and his accent, the accusation goes, so we hide our blue-state prejudices behind a mask of intellectual condescension.

But the more we learn about how Bush operates, the more we can see we were right from the beginning. It matters that the president values his gut reaction and disdains book learnin’. It’s not just a question of cultural style. The president’s narrow intellectual horizons have real consequences, sometimes cataclysmic ones.

Gary Hart Predicted That Invading Iraq Would Kick Open a ‘Hornet’s Nest’ in the Middle East

If this fool on a hill in West Hollywood could predict this outcome in 2002, it begs the question: Why couldn’t President Bush see where this perilous path would lead us?

When President Bush and his team began “marketing” (their word) the war in Iraq four years ago, former Sen. Gary Hart spoke out, predicting that Bush’s foolhardy enterrprise in Iraq would lead to a wider war. He was right:

Sometime in the fall of 2002, I likened a U.S. invasion of Iraq to “kicking open a hornets’ nest.” I predicted that, if the Iraqis decided to fight in the cities, our casualties would be between five and ten thousand U.S. troops at least. Now, U.S. casualties exceed 20,000.

But the “hornets’ nest” I predicted was not just an interminable and intractable U.S. occupation of Iraq. It was wider war in the Middle East. The larger hornets’ nest is now swarming.

By our justified overthrow of the Taliban in Afghanistan, though unsuccessful decapitation of al Qaeda, we removed a thorn in Iran’s side. By removing Saddam Hussein, we removed a thorn in Iran’s other side.

But, inadvertantly and ignorantly, we empowered Iran to undertake a major intervention on behalf of the Shiite majority in Iraq. In response to our insistence that Iran not develop any nuclear capability, Iran and Syria have emboldened Hezbullah in Lebanon to energize Israel’s formidable military and Hamas to do the same.

While I’m in told-ya-so mode, I have to say that I predicted it back then too, although I used the “Pandora’s Box” analogy. My prediction that our invasion of Iraq would unleash a plague of nasties was not based on psychic powers or extreme brilliance (not hardly) but on a basic grasp of the history of confict in the region.

If this fool on a hill in West Hollywood could predict this outcome in 2002, it begs the question: Why couldn’t President Bush see where this perilous path would lead us?

Novak’s Ever-Changing Version of How He Learned the CIA Agent’s Secret Identity

Alert the media! On Meet the Press today, Tim Russert came thisclose to grilling Bob Novak about inconsistencies in Novak’s recounting of events leading up to his revelation of CIA agent Valerie Plame’s identity:

MR. RUSSERT: Now, Newsday interviewed you a few weeks after your column ran, back in 2003, and quotes you as saying this, “I didn’t dig it out, it was given to me. They thought it was significant, they gave me the name and I used it.”

MR. NOVAK: That was a misstatement on my part. I … I’m … I’ve found I’m much better … I hope I’m not screwing up on this interview because I’m much better interviewing than I am giving interviews. They didn’t give me the name. And of course it was not a “they,” it was one person, which I later checked out with Mr. Rove. They, they … the Newsday article also paraphrased me as saying they came to me, I never said they came to me, because obviously I initiated the interview.

MR. RUSSERT: Newsday stands by that story. And you know if a politician said that, which you said, and contrasted it with what you’re saying now, people would say, “Wait a minute. Something’s wrong here.”

MR. NOVAK: Well, I was wrong when I said they came to me.

MR. RUSSERT: You…

MR. NOVAK: I mean, when I said that they gave me the name, because I got the name from, from “Who’s Who in America.’

MR. RUSSERT: You did say that the column — the story — the disclosure was inadvertent on the part of your primary source. A third party told you that.

MR. NOVAK: A third party close to the primary source called me after the investigation was launched and said, and said that he believed that it was … he believed he had given me inadvertent … inadvertently given me information … this information.

MR. RUSSERT: Have you spoken to your primary source?

MR. NOVAK: No.

MR. RUSSERT: Not since that interview?

MR. NOVAK: No.

MR. RUSSERT: When you were on MEET THE PRESS October of ’03, I asked you about the Newsday piece, and you did repeat, you said, quote, “What I meant was that the senior official had given me her name.”

MR. NOVAK: Well, that, that was just … that’s just a misstatement on my part. He, he … what he said exactly was his wife, his wife had done it. I got the name … because I, I, I realized I didn’t have the name, and I figured out, how am I going to get this name to put in, in the column? So I said, “Maybe it’s in “Who’s Who.” And I looked it up and there it was.

MR. RUSSERT: In fact, you wrote, “I learned Valerie Plame’s name from Joe Wilson’s entry in “Who’s Who” in America. And here is the “Who’s Who” from 2003, Wilson, Joseph Charles IV, ambassador, married to Valerie Elise Plame August 3, 1998. Was that the very first time you had seen or head the name Valerie Plame?

MR. NOVAK: Yes.

MR. RUSSERT: No one told you?

MR. NOVAK: No.

MR. RUSSERT: But they did tell you “his wife.”

MR. NOVAK: He told me his wife worked in the counterproliferation division of the … they did not say she was a covert operative, didn’t say she was a covered operative. A lot of people say, “Well, why’d you call her an operative in the column?” I call all kinds of politicians operatives. It’s maybe a bad habit, I … but I still do it. I see somebody’s running a congressional campaign in Wyoming, I’d call them an operative.

MR. RUSSERT: But having said twice before that you got the name of a senior official…

MR. NOVAK: Oh, a mistake.

MR. RUSSERT: …you can understand why people are…

MR. NOVAK: I understand, I understand, but it was … it’s just not a … it’s just not factually correct and I have, I have testified under oath about this.

MR. RUSSERT: You have?

MR. NOVAK: Yes.

MR. RUSSERT: That they did not give you the name?

MR. NOVAK: Yes.

Mayor Newsom on Political Courage and Gay Marriage

San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom on the Democratic Party’s faint heart on same-sex marriage:

Rolling Stone: Listening to the Democratic opposition to the federal anti-gay marriage amendment, the party’s senators sounded more like Dixiecrats — talking about marriage as a states’s rights issue — rather than Democrats, pursuing this from a civil-rights perspective.

Gavin Newsom: Where’s the moral courage? It’s lost. I have the luxury of saying this from San Francisco, I certainly respect what it’s like saying this in parts of Kentucky or North Carolina, but also believe this issue won’t go away for the Democratic party we stand up on historic principles.

We’ve never run the 90-yard dash on equality — ever. The history of this party is civil rights, women’s rights, human rights, labor rights, gay and lesbian rights. And for us to hold up civil unions and say that separate is somehow now equal — when just a-year-and-a-half we ago celebrated the 50th anniversary of Brown v. Board — is transparent to the people. They see through the Democrats.

Leader Boehner Follows Former Leader DeLay’s Path to K Street

House Majority Leader John Boehner never acknowledged the corruption in his party under the leadership of his predecessor, former Rep. Tom DeLay — so we shouldn’t be surprised that he’s not a reformer. But now it’s clear he’s out to make the DeLay era look, well, conservative:

Representative John A. Boehner won the job of House majority leader amid a post-Abramoff clamor for an overhaul of lobbying and ethics rules. But nearly six months later, the changes are still tied up in Congress.

And far from trying to put the brakes on lobbyists and the money they channel into Republican coffers, Mr. Boehner, who has portrayed his ties to Washington lobbyists as something to be proud of, has stepped on the gas.

He has been holding fund-raisers at lobbyists’ offices, flying to political events on corporate planes and staying at a golf resort with a business group that has a direct stake in issues before Congress.

Tapping a rich vein of longstanding relationships with lobbyists and their corporate clients, Mr. Boehner, an Ohio Republican, has raised campaign contributions at a rate of about $10,000 a day since February, surpassing the pace set by former Representative Tom DeLay after he became majority leader in 2002, a review of federal filings shows.

His fund-raising pace is roughly twice what it was before he became majority leader in February; in April his two federal committees took in $334,500 from political action committees, a monthly take that Mr. DeLay did not match for more than two years after the elections in 2002.

Mr. Boehner’s biggest donors include the political action committees of lobbying firms, drug and cigarette makers, banks, health insurers, oil companies and military contractors. Seven American Indian tribes with casinos have contributed $32,000.

German Child Screams in Terror at Sight of Pres. Bush’s Recent Weight Gain

Tubby: President Bush’s new girth has obviously terrified this German child. We’re not claiming to be the fittest of the fit, but the president is a notorious ridiculer of overweight people — hey, it’s what towel-snapping frat boys do — but we will take this opportunity to remind the president that if he would just resign today (and take Cheney with him), he could be back in Crawford tomorrow with nothing to do but work on his abs all day long.

Think about it, George. Nothing to do all day long but think about yourself. Come on! You know you want to…

NC11: GOP’s Taylor Trailer Dem Challenger

Interesting poll from the ancestral congressional district of our branch of the Ponder family, NC11, which includes Hendersonville and all points west:

Public Policy Polling (PDF). 7/10. Likely voters. MoE 3.7% (May results)

Without leaners

Taylor (R) 43 (42)
Shuler (D) 47 (46)

With leaners

Taylor (R) 45
Shuler (D) 51

After the recent fundraising numbers for the quarter, the candidates’ respective Cash on Hand numbers will reportedly look like this:

Taylor $100K
Shuler $550K

Looks incredible, until you remember that Charles Taylor is a gazillionaire and will be able to write himself as a large a check as necessary to trash the f’ out of Shuler.

Still, this race is living up to its top billing as one of the Republicans’ most endangered seats.