Palin Advocated End-of-Life ‘Death Panel’ Counseling in 2008

Nothing speaks to the degeneracy of the Republican Party more than its campaign to turn something as profoundly important as living wills and end-of-life counseling into something as scary sounding as “death panels,” which Facebook blogger Sarah Palin called “evil” last week.

But last year, when Palin was governor of Alaska, she was 100 percent behind end-of-life counseling. In fact, as governor, she decreed April 16, 2008, to be “Death Panel Day” — er, sorry — “Healthcare Decision Day”:

…Healthcare Decisions Day is designed to raise public awareness of the need to plan ahead for healthcare decisions, related to end of life care and medical decision-making whenever patients are unable to speak for themselves and to encourage the specific use of advance directives to communicate these important healthcare decisions…

[One] of the principal goals of Healthcare Decisions Day is to encourage hospitals, nursing homes, assisted living facilities, continuing care retirement communities, and hospices to participate in a statewide effort to provide clear and consistent information to the public about advance directives, as well as to encourage medical professionals and lawyers to volunteer their time and efforts to improve public knowledge and increase the number of Alaska’s citizens with advance directives…

[As] a result of April 16, 2008, being recognized as Healthcare Decisions Day in Alaska, more citizens will have conversations about their healthcare decisions; more citizens will execute advance directives to make their wishes known; and fewer families and healthcare providers will have to struggle with making difficult healthcare decisions in the absence of guidance from the patient.

Of course, there is no provision to create death panels in Section 1233 of one of the House reform bills. Sarah Palin knowingly lied about that.

So here’s a question: When is Sarah Palin goin’ to stop makin’ stuff up?

A Call to Arms from the Right: ‘It Is Time to Water the Tree of Liberty’ With Blood

The topic of assassination has been unthinkable during the early months of Barack Obama’s presidency. But in light of the right-wing rage on display at health-care town halls this month — combined with new information that the president is receiving around 900 threats per month, a 400 percent increase over threats against George Bush — the topic has unfortunately become a lot less unthinkable.

In an op-ed in the Washington Post today, David Broder suggests Republicans are “playing with fire” by fanning the flames with talk of incipient socialism and by promoting lies about reforms, including the lie that will not die, that Obama plans to set up “death panels” with the power to euthanize seniors and the handicapped.

Broder means GOP leaders are playing with fire politically, of course. Their objective in ginning up the hysteria is to drive a wedge between Blue Dog Dems and the right-leaning independents whose votes they must have to stay in office. Broder warns the GOP leaders that the party could face a backlash from normal Americans who find the rage of the town-hall disrupters off-putting and who see through the lies about reforms.

Broder — the capitol’s leading regurgitator of conventional wisdom — is not ready yet to accuse his GOP buddies (and key sources) of fanning the flames of violence. But a new metric about the threat level faced by this president should give pause even to David Broder, the ultimate promoter of the status quo.

According to a new book, “In the President’s Secret Service,” by Richard Kessler, Pres. Obama receives as many as 30 death threats a day. That’s as much as 900 threats a month — roughly 7,000 threats since the president was inaugurated.

Given statistical probability — combined with the fact that the right-wing fringe has produced Timothy McVeigh, Olympics bomber Eric Rudolph, Scott Roeder, the murderer of Dr. George Tiller, and other killers in recent years — it is a dead cinch that one of these lunatics will take the threat to the next level and launch a violent attack against the president someday soon.

Over the top, you say?

[…]

Read the Bill: Complete Text of Section of House Bill with Purported ‘Death Panel’ Provision

It’s a dead cinch that none of the folks screaming “Read the bill!” at members of Congress at health-care reform town hall meetings this month have actually read the bills themselves.

Top Republicans, including Sarah Palin, Newt Gingrich, House Minority Leader John Boehner, former New York Lt. Gov. Betsy McCaughey and others, are lying when they claim a provision in Section 1233, “Advance Care Planning Consultation,” sets up “death panels.”

By not reading the House bills — in particular, the one called “America’s Affordable Health Choices Act of 2009” — town hall disrupters who have also been railing about a purported provision in the bill that establishes “death panels” have revealed themselves to be hypocrites as well as willing dupes in a campaign by the medical lobbies and Republican leaders to kill reform in order to protect health-care profits.

Top Republicans, including Sarah Palin, Newt Gingrich, House Minority Leader John Boehner, former New York Lt. Gov. Betsy McCaughey and others — and just today Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa — are lying about the contents of Section 1233, “Advance Care Planning Consultation,” which they say requires elderly and infirm people to be evaluated by “death panels” every five years.

What the bill actually does is extend payments to Medicare recipients who seek professional counseling on end-of-life issues like setting up a living will and issuing “do not resuscitate” instructions to their families.

Facts do not matter to right-wingers, of course, but normal Americans who might take the Tea-baggers’ and Birthers’ venting about euthanasia at face value instead of seeing it for what it really is — rage over having a black president — need to know the truth.

The full text of Section 1233 follows:

[…]

Evolution of the GOP ‘Death Panel’ Big Lie, from ‘Evil’ to ‘Nuts’

The GOP’s false claim that the House health care bill includes a provision that would set up a death panel that would decide whether the elderly and handicapped should receive treatment was propagated initially by Betsy McCaughey, the former lieutenant governor of New York, who is a professional shill for the health-care industry. She first floated the lie in radio interview with Fred Thompson, the right-wing former television actor:

And one of the most shocking things I found in this bill, and there were many, is on Page 425, where the Congress would make it mandatory — absolutely require — that every five years, people in Medicare have a required counseling session that will tell them how to end their life sooner, how to decline nutrition, how to decline being hydrated, how to go in to hospice care. And by the way, the bill expressly says that if you get sick somewhere in that five-year period — if you get a cancer diagnosis, for example — you have to go through that session again. All to do what’s in society’s best interest or your family’s best interest and cut your life short. These are such sacred issues of life and death. Government should have nothing to do with this. [fredthompsonshow.com, interview archives, 07/16/09]

None of that is true. First of all, just imagine the logistics of “requiring” tens of millions of Medicare recipients to undergo counseling. The staffing costs alone would likely exceed whatever cost benefit that might be derived from euthanizing that many people. Secondly, euthanasia — also known as assisted suicide — is illegal in every state but Oregon, Washington and Montana.

What page 425 in the House bill — more formally known as Section 1233 — actually does is expand Medicare coverage to pay for counseling when people choose to set up living wills and make other decisions about end-of-life issues.

On July 23, House Minority Leader John Boehner of Ohio and Rep. Thaddeus McCotter (R-Mich.) helped spread the lie in an offical statement from the House Republican leadership:

This provision may start us down a treacherous path toward government-encouraged euthanasia if enacted into law… [It] is a throwback to 1977, when the old Department of Health Education and Welfare proposed federal promotion of living wills for cost-savings purposes described as ‘enormous.’ At that time, the late Cardinal Joseph Bernardin of Chicago decried this effort by saying: “The message is clear: government can save money by encouraging old people to die a little sooner than they otherwise would. Instead of being regarded with reverence, and cherished, human life is subject in this view to a utilitarian cost-benefit calculus and can be sacrificed to serve fiscal policy and the sacred imperative of trimming a budget.”

[…]

If Private Sector Is Better at Solving Health Insurance Crisis, What’s Stopping It?

Here’s a fundamental fact, maybe the fundamental fact, that has been obscured in the debate over health insurance reform: We wouldn’t need a government option if the private sector had a plan for covering everyone, and the only reason the plans don’t cover everyone is greed.

The bottom line for the health-insurance industry is that it is cheaper to kill reform than it is to solve the crisis.

Think about it. The health companies have had since they killed the Clinton plan in 1993 to get their collective act together. Instead, premiums are up, fewer people are covered and the public’s collective health and well-being is in decline.

Conservatives assert that only the private sector can solve the insurance crisis — an assertion that ignores the fact that the military, veterans, federal workers and members of Congress, including even Republican congressmen — are covered by government-run plans that perform comparatively well.

Still, let’s assume for a moment that what conservatives say is true — that only the private sector can fix the problem — then here is a question:

What is stopping it?

[…]

Truly Evil: Palin Exploits Down Syndrome Son in Health-Care Reform Debate

From the moment she signed on as the Republican vice-presidential nominee last year, Sarah Palin has made a habit of using her children as political props but then denouncing the media for reporting on it when she thrusts her kids into the spotlight.

Palin’s exploitation of her children took a nasty turn on Friday when she lied on her Facebook page about a provision in the reform proposals that would pay for consultations on end-of-life options:

“And who will suffer the most when they ration care?” Palin asks. “The sick, the elderly, and the disabled, of course. The America I know and love is not one in which my parents or my baby with Down Syndrome will have to stand in front of Obama’s ‘death panel’ so his bureaucrats can decide, based on a subjective judgment of their ‘level of productivity in society,’ whether they are worthy of health care. Such a system is downright evil.”

If any part of what she wrote were true, it would be evil. But what is truly evil is a politician who is so corrupt and degenerate that she would use her handicapped child as a prop to illustrate a lie.

DNC Ad Goes After GOP’s Astroturf Tea-Bagger Anti-Reform Flash Mobs

The Democratic National Party has released a web ad that unmasks this summer’s Republicans astroturf campaign of deploying tea-baggers to disrupt health-care town halls and other events. The ad exposes the fact that the people shown in cell-phone videos of the disruptions are not the angry constituents confronting their elected representatives they pretend to be, but rather are tea-baggers bussed into the districts to shut down discussion about reform.

While the current GOP campaign seems to be working so far — meaning the visuals from the videos are likely duping millions of low-info voters — the party’s record on astroturfing has had mixed results over the past decade.

From DU: Identities of Brooks Brothers “rioters” revealed

The GOP’s first astroturf action was the “Brooks Brothers riot” in 2000, when a handful of paid operatives were parachuted into Miami to as part of its campaign to shut down the Bush v. Gore recounts. (There’s a list of the operatives and who they worked for here.)

At the time, the hapless mainstream media portrayed the “riot” as if it were a legitimate outburst of outrage by concerned Floridians. It was just one in a series of successful tactics that helped the GOP abscond with the presidency in 2000, with disastrous results for the country and the world over the ensuing eight years.

[…]

Olbermann Names Reform-Killers in Both Parties Who Are Prostituting Themselves for the Medical Lobbies

In his Special Comment on MSNBC’s “Countdown” last night, Keith Olbermann called out prominent members of Congress who are working to kill health-care reform, accusing them of prostituting themselves to the health industry lobbies.

“We know what you are, sir, we’re arguing about the price.”
— Olbermann addressing Sen. Thune (R-N.D.), who has been paid $1.2 million by medical lobbies to kill health care reform

In particular, he accused Sen. John Thune, R-S.D., of lying in his follow-up to the president’s weekly address last week when Thune said the Democrats’ reform proposals would produce ” … government run health care that would disrupt our current system and force millions of Americans who currently enjoy their employer-based coverage into a new health care plan run by government bureaucrats.” (The Republicans’ meme that government bureaucrats are worse than, say, Blue Cross or United bureaucrats never ceases to rankle.)

Sen. Thune — whose family benefits from a very nice health care plan run by government bureaucrats — has received $1.2 million in donations from medical lobbies, according to Olbermann.

Olbermann also called out Rep. Ginny Brown-Waite (R-Fla.), who said on the House floor that in their reform proposals, Democrats were saying to America’s seniors: “Drop dead.” Rep. Brown-Waite has received $369,255 from the lobbies.

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky has received $3.1 million; Rep. Joe Barton, R-Ok., has taken $2.6 million; and Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. has been paid $1.6 million to kill health care reform.

And then there’s Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., the chairman of the Finance Committee who has done as much as anyone to kill the government option. He has taken in $2.6 million from various medical industry groups, according to Olbermann.

Others members of Congress cited by Olbermann as turning tricks for the medical lobbies include Rep. Bart Gordon, R-Tenn., ($1.17 million); Rep. John Tanner, D-Tenn., ($215,000); Rep. Mike Ross, D-Ark.; Sen. Kay Hagan, D-N.C.; Rep. Earl Pomeroy, D-N.D.; Sen. Thomas Carper, D-Del.; and Sen. Blanche Lincoln, D-Ark.

Transcript:

[…]

Senate GOP to Oppose More Funding for Popular, Successful ‘Clunkers’ Stimulus Program

The “Cash for Clunkers” program has been a success by all metrics. Car buyers who traded in their older cars for up to $4,500 in downpayments for new, more energy efficent vehicles depleted the program’s $1 billion funding within the first week. As many as 250,000 cars were sold last week, according to government estimates.

These sales benefited the local economies in the hometowns of the dealerships as well as, ultimately, the auto industry.

So who would oppose adding another $2 billion to this win-win deal? You guessed it. The Party of No:

“My children and grandchildren are going to have to pay for these cars and we’re helping auto dealers while there are thousands of other small businesses that aren’t getting the help,” said Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.) during an appearance on Fox News Sunday. “The role of the federal government is not to run the used car business.”

“We’re definitely going to debate it and I’ve heard that John McCain is going to stand up and try to stop it and I’m going to work with him every way that I can,” he said. “This is crazy to try to rush this thing through again.”

“I just think this is a great example of the stupidity that’s coming out of Washington right now, and I think Americans realize the numbers that we’re throwing around don’t work,” DeMint added.

Unless these pols are looking at polling that shows that no Republican voters are taking advantage of this deal — and the chances of that are next to nil — this kneejerk opposition is even crazier than the rest.

Local Publisher Regrets Not Covering Hate Crime Murder of Ryan Skipper

Just ran across this item in the Daily City and had to pass it along. In an interview about the 15th anniversary of the founding of Watermark, a gay news source serving Tampa Bay and other Florida metro areas, publisher Tom Dyer acknowledged missing an important story in his market and to the nation:

In the final analysis, Ryan Skipper was assaulted twice — first, fatally by his homophobic killers and then in the media by the homophobic sheriff of Polk County.

[Daily City]: In 15 years of publishing Watermark, what has been your biggest regret?

Tom Dyer: We should have jumped on the Ryan Skipper story immediately. This young Polk County man’s murder just a few years ago was every bit as gruesome as Matthew Shepard’s, and every bit as telling about the persistence of violent homophobia in our area. There was almost no coverage in the mainstream press, and I let that influence my judgment. Big mistake, and I still regret it.

The fact that there was no coverage in the mainstream media about Ryan’s death in March 2007 is directly attributable to egregious malpractice by the top law enforcement official involved in the case, Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd.

At his first news conference about the case, four days or so after the murder and hours after the arrests of Joe Bearden and William Brown, a couple of young meth heads with criminal records, Judd presented the media with a tick-tock of events around the murder that was based entirely on accounts given to investigators by Bearden and Brown.

According to Judd, Ryan — a clean-cut, 25-year-old student — was out looking for rough trade that night and picked up Bearden in what was purported to be a known cruising area in the rural community of Wahneta. He then took Bearden home where, interestingly, they did not have sex but instead smoked pot and schemed to forge checks using Ryan’s computer.

That mistaken profiling of a gay victim would be bad enough, but the clincher came in Judd’s own take on what happened:

“What we do know is that Ryan was looking for someone to pick up that evening. And unfortunately for Ryan, he picked up the wrong person.”

In other words, Ryan was asking to be murdered and got what he deserved.

[…]