Origins of the Tea Bagger Movement: Santelli’s Rant, Ron Paul’s Fundraiser or a 1974 Pro-Segregation Rally in Boston?

There is a debate out there about the origins of the tea bagger movement. Some say it was during a rant by CNBC’s Rick Santelli on Thursday, Feb. 19, 2009, about the new administration’s plan to help mortgage holders who were underwater:

RICK SANTELLI: The government is promoting bad behavior. Because we certainly don’t want to put stimulus forth and give people a whopping $8 or $10 in their check, and think that they ought to save it, and in terms of modifications… I’ll tell you what, I have an idea.

You know, the new administration’s big on computers and technology– How about this, President and new administration? Why don’t you put up a website to have people vote on the Internet as a referendum to see if we really want to subsidize the losers’ mortgages; or would we like to at least buy cars and buy houses in foreclosure and give them to people that might have a chance to actually prosper down the road, and reward people that could carry the water instead of drink the water?

TRADER ON FLOOR: That’s a novel idea.

(Applause, cheering [by employees of the exchange behind him on the trading floor])

JOE KERNEN: Hey, Rick… Oh, boy. They’re like putty in your hands. Did you hear…?

SANTELLI: No they’re not, Joe. They’re not like putty in our hands. This is America! How many of you people want to pay for your neighbor’s mortgage that has an extra bathroom and can’t pay their bills? Raise their hand.

(Booing)

President Obama, are you listening?

TRADER: How ’bout we all stop paying our mortgage? It’s a moral hazard.

KERNEN: It’s like mob rule here. I’m getting scared. I’m glad I’m…

CARL QUINTANILLA: Get some bricks and bats…

SANTELLI: Don’t get scared, Joe. They’re already scaring you. You know, Cuba used to have mansions and a relatively decent economny. They moved from the individual to the collective. Now, they’re driving ‘54 Chevys, maybe the last great car to come out of Detroit.

KERNEN: They’re driving them on water, too, which is a little strange to watch.

SANTELLI: There you go.

KERNEN: Hey Rick, how about the notion that, Wilbur pointed out, you can go down to 2 percent on the mortgage…

SANTELLI: You could go down to -2 percent. They can’t afford the house.

KERNEN: …and still have 40 percent, and still have 40 percent not be able to do it. So why are they in the house? Why are we trying to keep them in the house?

SANTELLI: I know Mr. Summers is a great economist, but boy, I’d love the answer to that one.

REBECCA QUICK: Wow. Wilbur, you get people fired up.

SANTELLI: We’re thinking of having a Chicago Tea Party in July. All you capitalists that want to show up to Lake Michigan, I’m gonna start organizing.

(Whistling, cheering)

The Ron Paul wing of the right-wing fringe believes the tea bag movement was born a year earlier, in December when Paul’s quixotic campaign for the presidency surprised Beltway types by breaking single-day fundraising records — taking in $6 million — on the 234th anniversary of the actual Boston Tea Party.

The third possibility — shown in the video at the top — comes from another libertarian source, Reason magazine:

While submerged in the WGBH archives, watching old clips on the busing battles that gripped South Boston in the 1970s, I came across this “The 10 O’Clock News” coverage of a September 9, 1974, rally at Government Center denouncing Judge W. Arthur Garrity, who ordered the desegregation of Southie schools. Sen. Ted Kennedy attempts to calm the crowd, but is shouted down and pelted with newspapers and tomatoes.

The WGBH anchor notes a “new touch” to the protest movement, “the abundance of teabags, apparently to signify that the demonstrators were in the same vein of those who tipped the tea into the harbor.”

Olbermann Apologizes for Forgetting to Call Sen.-Elect Scott Brown a ‘Sexist’

Earlier this week, Keith Olbermann sparked howls of derision from tea baggers and their ilk when he called now Sen.-Elect Scott Brown (TBP-Mass.) “an irresponsible, homophobic, racist, reactionary, ex-nude model, tea-bagging supporter of violence against women and against politicians with whom he disagrees.” In this video segment, Olbermann apologizes — because he left out “sexist.” He also offers proof for each of his charges and dares those who are complaining to refute any of them.

In Victory Speech, New Tea Bagger Senator Offered His Daughters to ‘Anybody Who’s Watching’ – Even Glenn Beck Is Offended

Most Americans were introduced to Scott Brown, the Tea Bagger Massachusetts elected to fill Sen. Ted Kennedy’s seat, when he delivered his victory speech Tuesday night. But near the top of the speech when he was introducing his family, Brown went rogue, abandoning the speech for an ad lib that was extremely inappropriate.

Transcript:

SEN. SCOTT BROWN (TBP-Mass): And as always, I rely on Gail’s love and support and that of our two lovely daughters. So I want to thank Ayla and Arianna for their help as well. And just in case anybody who’s watching throughout the country — yes, they’re both available.

No, no no. Only kidding. Only kidding. Arianna is definitely not available, but Ayla is.

GAIL BROWN (wife of senator): STOP!

SCOTT BROWN: (Grabs Arianna’s arm.) This is Arianna. (Grabs Ayla’s arm.) This is Ayla. Well, I can see I’m gonna get in trouble when I get home.

Right-wing pols who tout “family values” but cheat on their wives with impunity are so commonplace that regular Americans are seemingly inured to their philandering. But Brown’s unfunny use of his victory speech to pimp his daughters like he was on an Internet porn site even upset Fox News’ Glenn Beck — who once called Pres. Obama a racist, and so should know from inappropriate:

“I want a chastity belt on this man. I want his every move watched in Washington. I don’t trust this guy. This one could end with a dead intern.”
– Glen Beck

Conservative talk show host Glenn Beck slammed Brown’s acceptance speech on his show Wednesday — specifically for broadcasting on national television that his two daughters are currently “available.” Beck appeared to compare Brown to Gary Condit, the former Democratic congressman who some suspected was involved in the disappearance of his mistress and congressional intern Chandra Levy, who was found dead.

“I want a chastity belt on this man,” Beck said. “I want his every move watched in Washington. I don’t trust this guy. This one could end with a dead intern.”

Beck has questioned Brown before, writing in his Fox News column recently: “I don’t trust Scott Brown yet. Americans don’t know him.”

Bonus Video: A Cutesy Ad with Scott Brown & Daughters

H/t: Keith Olbermann on Countdown

Pat Robertson Should Know About Divine Vengeance – God Smote Him with a Hurricane in ’98

This is an updated repost of an article originally published in 2006.

Pat Robertson’s decree on Jan. 6 that the 7.0 earthquake that struck Haiti on Monday was a curse from God may be his most bizarre attribution of God’s vengeance yet:

As Haitian Prime Minister Jean-Max Bellerive said “well over” 100,000 people may have died in the natural disaster, Robertson took to the airwaves Wednesday on his show and said that the country has been “cursed by one thing after another” since they “swore a pact to the devil.”

“Something happened a long time ago in Haiti and people might not want to talk about,” Robertson said Tuesday.

“They were under the heel of the French, you know Napoleon the third and whatever. And they got together and swore a pact to the devil. They said ‘We will serve you if you will get us free from the prince.’ True story. And so the devil said, ‘Ok it’s a deal.’ And they kicked the French out. The Haitians revolted and got something themselves free. But ever since they have been cursed by one thing after another,” Robertson said.

Keep in mind that as Robertson said this, as far as anyone knew, tens of thousands of people were trapped and dying under collapsed buildings in Port au Prince.

It’s hard to say whether this utterance from Robertson tops his take in 2005 on Hurricane Katrina, which he attributed to God’s retribution for legalized abortion:

“I was reading, yesterday, a book that was very interesting about what God has to say in the Old Testament about those who shed innocent blood — But have we found we are unable somehow to defend ourselves against some of the attacks that are coming against us, either by terrorists or now by natural disaster? Could they be connected in some way?”

A year later, Robertson predicted that God would punish Oregon and Washington state because their coastal enclaves were populated by liberals:

Robertson says God has told him that storms and possibly a tsunami will hit America’s coastline this year. The founder of the Christian Broadcasting Network has told viewers of “The 700 Club” that the revelations came to him during his annual personal prayer retreat in January.

“If I heard the Lord right about 2006, the coasts of America will be lashed by storms,” Robertson said May 8. He added specifics in Wednesday’s show. “There well may be something as bad as a tsunami in the Pacific Northwest,” he said.

But Robertson’s record at foretelling the weather is as lousy as his record for prophesying heavenly damnation. In 1998, Robertson predicted all sorts of disasters would smite central Florida:

After Orlando … city officials voted in 1998 to fly rainbow flags from city lampposts during the annual Gay Days event at Disney World, Robertson issued the city a warning: “I don’t think I’d be waving those flags in God’s face if I were you. … [A] condition like this will bring about the destruction of your nation. It’ll bring about terrorist bombs, it’ll bring earthquakes, tornadoes and possibly a meteor.”

But it was Robertson whom God smote. A few months after he called down God’s wrath on Orlando, God hurled Hurricane Bonnie directly at Robertson’s compound on Virginia Beach:

Overnight, Bonnie drifted out into the Atlantic southeast of Kitty Hawk, North Carolina … Rough surf pounded the Atlantic coastline as far north as New England, while 12- to 15-foot swells were reported along the Virginia coast. Winds as high as 90 mph snapped ship mooring ropes and left hundreds of thousands of people without electricity on Friday in the Virginia Beach-Norfolk area.

God’s reason for punishing Robertson is unclear. Perhaps it was in retaliation for Robertson’s propensity for passing judgment on others despite the biblical edit, “Judge not, lest ye be judged” — or maybe it was Robertson’s practice of shaking down elderly women for donations to his “Operation Blessing” and then using their “widows’ mites” to fund transport operations for the lucrative diamond-mining operations he owned in Zaire.

Only God knows the truth.

Tea Baggers Demand Transparency from Dems But Ban Media from Convention

photo-tepra-baprg-hatOn Jan. 11, FreedomWorks — the corporate-funded, Washington-based community organizers behind the astroturfing of the Tea Bagger movement — put up a petition demanding that Democrats allow the media to cover health-care reform negotiation.

On that same day, organizers of next month’s Tea Party convention announced that, except for a small group of hand-picked propagandists, the media will not be allowed to cover their meeting at a luxury hotel in Nashville:

Word from Nashville on Monday was that the First National Tea Party Convention next month will be closed to the press, other than for a limited number of “selected” journalists. No word on who or how many.

This from the people who brought us last summer’s media-saturated Town Hall meetings…

Convention spokesman Judson Phillips informs us that most of the sessions are closed “at the request” of the presenters. “Given the media interest, I don’t want the sessions disrupted and overrun with the media,” he said…

If the secrecy sounds a little, well, un-American, Phillips has this explanation: It’s not a political convention, but a “working convention.”

It appears that sometimes the right of the people to peaceably assemble is best conducted out of view.

It is par for the course that there is a media blackout of the keynote speech by Sarah Palin on Saturday night, Feb. 6. But this event is sounding less like a grass-rootsy political affair by the minute. In addition to succumbing to the right wing’s irresistible impulse for secrecy and jackboot control of the media, tickets for the event in its fancy venue are priced for the elite at nearly $600 per person. (As this is being written, the convention website says tickets for the full meeting are sold out, but tickets for the Palin speech Saturday night are still available at $349.)

What this shows is that the new Tea Bag Party (TBP) is quickly taking on the qualities of a typical political party: Money-grubbing, dysfunction, hypocrisy and elitism.

When House Majority Leader Dick Armey Called Rep. Frank a ‘Fag,’ No One Called for Him to Resign

Republicans are trying to gin up an equivalence between this comment about then-Sen. Barack Obama by Democratic Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid during the 2008 presidential campaign:

[Reid] was wowed by Obama’s oratorical gifts and believed that the country was ready to embrace a black presidential candidate, especially one such as Obama — a “light-skinned” African American “with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one,” as he later put it privately.

…And this statement by former GOP Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott during festivities at the 100th birthday party for Sen. Strom Thurmond in 2002:

LOTT: “I want to say this about my state: When Strom Thurmond ran for president, we voted for him. We’re proud of it. And if the rest of the country had followed our lead, we wouldn’t have had all these problems over all these years, either.”

But there is no fair comparison between calling someone a “Negro” — the appellation preferred by African-Americans 40 years ago — and suggesting that America’s ills can be laid at the feet of uppity black people.

After his gaffe, Lott was essentially fired as majority leader by Karl Rove, who preferred the more malleable Sen. Bill Frist for the job. In the current kerfuffle, Pres. Obama personally accepted Reid’s apology. Yesterday, however, GOP Michael Steele called on Reid to resign and accused Democrats of having a double standard. Since Lott had to resign, so should Reid, Steele said. Since then, all the usual Republican suspects have rushed to the cameras to ditto the demand that Reid should go.

While it is plain silly to compare these two gaffes by majority leaders, there is a relatively recent scandal in which a Republican majority leader suffered no repercussions after he insulted a fellow congressman by calling him a “fag.” The leader was Dick Armey, who now heads Freedomworks, the outfit that astroturfed the Tea Bagger movement:

The House majority leader, Representative Dick Armey of Texas, set off a dispute on Capitol Hill today when he referred to Representative Barney Frank, one of several openly homosexual members of Congress, as “Barney Fag.”

Mr. Armey said later that he had simply mispronounced Mr. Frank’s name. First privately and then in addressing the House, he apologized to Mr. Frank for the remark, which he had made in an interview with a group of radio broadcasters.

No one believed Armey’s assertion that he’d had a slip of the tongue, including Rep. Frank:

[In] an interview with reporters after he and Mr. Armey had spoken privately, [Frank] seemed clearly upset. He said the remark reflected “a climate of meanness and intolerance with the Republicans.” While he declined to undertake a full-fledged attack in response, he also refused to wholly accept Mr. Armey’s apology.

“I don’t think it was on the tip of his tongue, but I do believe it was in the back of his mind,” Mr. Frank said. “There are a lot of ways to mispronounce my name. That is the least common.”

Armey’s name-calling occurred in January 1995, just weeks after Republicans took control of the House for the first time in 40 years — since voters tossed them out on their ears in the wake of the GOP’s communist witch hunts and other scandals. Here’s what the majority leader said:

“[House Speaker Newt Gingrich is] a very patient fellow and able to handle a harangue going on around him better than I,” Mr. Armey said. “I like peace and quiet, and I don’t have to listen to Barney Fag — Barney Frank — haranguing in my ear…”

There is a double standard here, but has nothing to do with the gaffes by Sens. Reid and Lott. What this shows is that it is okay with Republicans if one of their leaders calls a colleague a “fag,” but it is outrageous — a fireable offense — if a Democrat calls a black person a “Negro.”

Tea Bag Party to Hold First Convention – Palin Reportedy Being Paid $100k to Speak

Sarah Palin in full Tea Bagger regalia (found on the Internets)
Sarah Palin in full Tea Bagger regalia (uncredited photo)

With the mid-term elections looming, it is clear that the Tea Baggers’ populist, anti-Obama energy is being channeled into the the formation of a new national political party. With funding from wealthy right-wing extremists, including the Koch brothers and others, political operatives like former House Majority Leader-turned lobbyist Dick Armey have masterfully astroturfed the Tea Baggers into a new power base comprised of the most easily duped and manipulated segment of American society: poorly educated, white Southerners and their counterparts in other regions.

The objective of the astroturfing is to organize working-class opposition to government regulation of the sources of corporate wealth — energy, health care, the media, etc. — and roll back and eventually kill government policies and programs such as Medicare, Social Security and Civil Rights protections that help, yes, working class Americans. It could be said that the corporate oligarchs are attempting to create a 21st century version of the Dixiecrat Party, which, in 1948, had a platform that is nearly identical to Tea Bagger positions today: local control, shrinking the federal government and — although this goes unstated, it’s there in the optics at the rallies — racial segregation.

The connections between the corporate oligarchs and their rent-boys like Armey are relatively easy to research. But Tea Baggers themselves are oblivious to their roles as the pawns in this new power grab. They have been kept in the dark because, over the past decade and more, conservatives have trained their base to trust only right-wing media outlets like hate radio and Fox News, and these outlets scrupulously avoid reporting on who is pulling the strings and why.

For regular Americans, however, the connections are hard to miss. In the weeks leading up to the Koch-funded Freedomwork’s Tea Bagger rallies last summer, for example, right-wing billionaire Rupert Murdoch’s Fox News gave the rallies hundreds of hours of free promotion. On the day of the rallies, Fox covered the live events wall-to-wall, frequently displaying racist anti-Obama signs on its air without comment. Just last month, Bill O’Reilly, the senior propagandist at Fox, did a segment cheerleading the formation of the Tea Bag Party (TBP), citing a poll that found that 41 percent of Americans favor the TBP over Democrats (35 percent) and Republicans (28 percent).

“Well, look,” O’Reilly told his panel of TBP supporters — no representative of the other parties were included to make the discussion, you know, “fair and balanced” — “if you want a viable third party, you got to break it down. I mean, you just got to kick the door in like [1992 third-party candidate Ross] Perot did and other people did.”

There’s even a Tea Bagger social-network group on Murdoch’s Wall St. Journal website promoting the formation of a national political party because — speaking of easily duped — the GOP and Dems are too cozy with corporate interests:

This is good news for the nation. Both the Republican and the Democrat party have been serving the private corporations for a long time. Everyone sees what has happened to this country are [sic] both their watches; they have failed. Leaving, or not running again is best for the USA. The ststaes [sic] need to fill out the proper forms and certify the TEA polictical [sic] party in their state. Do it, stop talking and blogging about it, actually do it and register a few TEA candidates for 2010. The time to act is now, not later. Returning to the American Constitution is correct, turning away from corporation bylaws is correct, watching these unAmerican kickbackers leave in [sic] good for the country. Jorge Lovenguth TEA Florida

At least one state group has made it official. Last November, right-wingers in Florida filled out the paperwork to register the TBP as an official political party in the state.

Around the same time, organizers announced that Tea Baggers would be holding a convention, Feb. 4 – 6, in Nashville. As it stands now, Sarah Palin has agreed to address the mob as the keynote speaker for the closing-night banquet. (There will be bibs.)

Palin is, of course, most famous for quitting and/or not showing up, and one pro-Tea Bag insider (he says he believes that “Palin and the grassroots Tea Party efforts are forces for good”) reports that Palin will be paid as much as $100,000 for the gig.

This calls into question the legitimacy of the Tea Baggers’ meeting in Nashville. Is it a step toward the birth of a national racist political party, or is it just a for-profit mass meeting to shake down America’s most hapless half-wits — a political version of an Amway convention?

If it is the former, it represents the first time a putative front-runner presidential candidate required payment to address her party. If so, it also shines a light on the astroturfing of this movement. If the Tea Baggers were a legitimate grass roots movement, they could have easily invited Rep. Michelle Bachmann, R-Minn., a whackjob easily as looney-tunes as Palin, who would have spoken for free.

Writing back in November, even the Tea Bagger sympathizer is suspicious about the real purpose of the convention:

The schedule mentions break-out and discussion sessions with no topics, no list of moderators, etc. It’s unclear what anyone will be doing in Nashville for three days other than waiting for Sarah Palin. On top of that, the planning looks to be very poorly done.

The conference sessions, whatever they may be, end at 12:30 PM Saturday afternoon. There’s nothing happening again until the banquet at 6 PM that night. In most cases, all that will achieve is driving up participation costs due to the need for another night in a hotel. Attendees traveling any distance to the event would be all but forced to travel home on a Sunday. That may be fine if one is looking to maximize revenue for the area and some hotels. But it doesn’t seem to take Tea Party goers interests in mind at all.

But if the past is prologue with Palin, the controversy over whether she’s being paid to speak to her followers will soon be shoved aside for the eternal question about her: Will she show up, or will she quit the event before Feb. 6?