Let’s Play the Blame Game

In its Inside Washington poll, the National Journal surveyed congressional leaders and Capitol Hill insiders from both parties were asked to grade the performance of the main actors on the Katrina stage. The overall grades were pretty predictable: Bush D+, Chertoff D, Brown F, Blanco D+, Nagin D+, Hastert D.

Far more entertaining were the comments from those polled. Here’s the game: Match up the comment with the actor and the party affiliation of the commenter. Answers are below.

1. “Five-week vacations while the country is at war are bad .… So, too, is appointing anyone other than experienced professionals to emergency-management positions. And never fly over disaster areas in a jet.”

2. “He’s really clueless on these issues, but has at least brought some clarity to the message.”

3. “He has led the single most inept performance by the government since Jimmy Carter’s helicopters all malfunctioned while trying to rescue our hostages in Iran in 1980.”

4. “Flat-out not up to the task of strong leadership after a disaster.”

5. “ [He] is his own disaster. The Bush administration has wisely put him so far underground now that it will take a National Guard rescue team to find him.”

6. “He may be right substantively, but it’s a case of political deafness when deftness was required.”

7. “Definitely not the Rudy Giuliani of New Orleans.”

8. “Hysterical at times, he offered a poor comparison to Giuliani’s heroic performance in the rubble of the Trade Center.”

9. “It was bad enough that Bush sat for seven minutes after he first heard of the events on 9/11, but to do nothing on the Gulf Coast for four days is beyond belief.”

10. “If Trent Lott lost his leadership post in the Senate for racial insensitivity, what should happen to [him] for writing off an entire city?”

ANSWERS: 1. Bush, R; 2. Chertoff, R; 3. Brown, D; 4. Blanco, D; 5. Brown, D; 6. Hastert, D; 7. Nagin, R; 8. Nagin, D; 9. Bush, R; 10. Hastert, R.

FEMA Fiction: Brownie’s Padded Resume

In over his head: Time Magazine has looked into the resume of FEMA Director Michael Brown, and has found some, er, irregularities.

By now, everybody knows that he was the general counsel for the International Arabian Horse Association before he went to work for his college roommate, Joe Allbaugh, the director of FEMA. (Allbaugh got the FEMA job because he was a camapaign operative for Bush/Cheney in 2000.)

But the one position prior to his stint at FEMA that seemed to have had anything to do with disaster preparedness was “serving as an assistant city manager with emergency services oversight” for a small town in Oklahoma in the 1970’s.

Wrong. Brownie, who was in his twenties, was actually an “assistant to the city manager” of Edmond, OK. In other words, he was the city manager’s administrative assistant, or secretary.

Brown also apparently lied about receiving the “Outstanding Political Science Professor” award at an Oklahoma university. In fact, he was a student, not a professor, at the school.

He also claimed to be a director of the Oklahoma Christian Home, but a spokesperson for the home said Brown “was never director here, was never on the board of directors, was never executive director. He was never here in any capacity. I never heard his name mentioned here.”

A former boss remembers Brown this way: “He did mainly transactional work, not litigation,” says Jones. “There was a feeling that he was not serious and somewhat shallow.”

A D.C. Kool Kid Seems to Have Awakened, Is Shocked to Discover The President Is Callous and Inept

But it’s too late now: The Hurricane Katrina disaster has awakened Margaret Carlson, one of the cadre of “liberal” D.C. Kool Kids whose laser focus on the Clintons’ personal lives in the 1990’s gave aid and comfort to the enemy, thus helping to deliver the White House to the Republicans in 2000.

That was then. This is Margaret now:

The Bushes have always made fun of Bill Clinton’s lip-biting, hands-on governing, but who wouldn’t prefer it to this president’s upbeat platitudes.

Who, indeed – but it wasn’t just the Bushes who derided President Clinton, Margaret. It was you, too.

[…]

DHS’s Chertoff Had Powers He Didn’t Exercise

Remarkable restraint: Department of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff had broad powers to circumvent state authorities in the days leading up to Hurricane Katrina’s landfall on the Gulf Coast. Question is, why didn’t he exercise them?

According to Chris Strohm, writing for GoveExec.com, DHS could have bypassed state and local authorities to stage material and relief supplies in the critical days leading up to the storm.

The federal government has been criticized during the past week for being slow to respond to the hurricane’s impact, especially with regard to the situation in New Orleans, where levees broke on Tuesday, flooding the city, killing thousands and leaving tens of thousands stranded for days with no food, water or medical care.

Homeland Security officials have said in their defense that they pre-positioned resources before the hurricane struck, but had to wait for the states to request federal assistance before they could fully move into the affected regions.

During an interview on CBS’ Face the Nation last Sunday, Chertoff offered up another in what is becoming a long list of ultra-banal quotes:

“I think that the lesson of this hurricane, which we will clearly look at as we go over an after-action evaluation, is going to be very valuable moving forward. This was an ultracatastrophe, but we have to be prepared even for ultracatastrophes, even things that happen once in a lifetime, or once in a generation.”

The government’s National Response Plan gives DHS broad authority to respond to catastrophes, even if it means bypassing state and local governments. What isn’t clear is whether Chertoff fully used that power.
[…]

President’s Approval Slips Slightly Among Republicans

Gops awaken: Most polls taken since the Hurricane Katrina destroyed the Gulf Coast show that public approval of President Bush is declining. What is causing the decline?

Andy Kohut, director of the Pew poll says, “Uncharacteristically, the president’s ratings have slipped most among his core constituents — Republicans and conservatives.”

In the Pew survey, Republicans gave President Bush a job approval rating of 79 percent – down from 88 percent in July. Among Democrats, his approval was 19 percent compared with 18 percent in July, and among independents it was 33 percent versus 32 percent.

Pelosi Steps Up

In the wake of the Hurricane Katrina disaster, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) has stepped up to the plate. First she revealed tht President Bush had indicated to her personally that he was clueless (or lying to her face) about the ineptitude of his unqualified FEMA Director Michael Brown.

Today in an interview on CNN, she went toe to toe with newsreader Kyra Phillips who seemed to be sitting in for White House political director:

PHILLIPS: I think it’s unfair that FEMA is just singled out. There are so many people responsible for what has happened in the state of Louisiana.

PELOSI: Well, that’s true. That is true. And I’m sorry that you think it’s unfair. But I don’t. I think it’s unfair to the people who lost their family members, their lives, their livelihoods, their homes, their opportunity.

And FEMA has done a poor job. It had no chance. It was (INAUDIBLE)…

PHILLIPS: But what about all those warnings…

PELOSI: … may I please respond?

PHILLIPS: What about all the warnings from the Army Corps of Engineers…

PELOSI: But the Army Corps of Engineers…

PHILLIPS: … years ago, saying there’s a problem with these levees, there’s a problem with this city…

PELOSI: … if you want to make a case for the White House, you should go on their payroll.

Crooks & Lias has the video.

UPS Sends Two Liaisons; FEMA, Governors Still Not Speaking

FEMA still hasn’t figured out to make nice with the folks it’s supposedly trying to help. As UPS, the shipping giant, tries to aid in Gulf Coast relief, it sounds as if FEMA still isn’t talking to the governors. UPS:

UPS today announced it had begun working directly with the governors of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama to support the Hurricane Katrina relief effort.

In Louisiana, Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco has organized a team to help direct the state’s emergency relief effort. UPS is supporting the distribution and logistics efforts of that team.

In consultation with Gov. Blanco and also with Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour, UPS has placed individual liaison officers at the command of the state governments. Two hurricane relief officers have been assigned to each of the two states, one to the governor and a second to the top Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) official in the state. These UPS managers will remain accessible at all time to ensure that any emergency movement of food or supplies is handled as promptly as possible.

Can you say, “duplication?” Very good! Now can you say, “FEMA incompetence?” I thought you could!

As the federal government struggles to accomplish anything beyond roughing people up and justifying its poor performance, at least UPS is “gittin’ ‘er done.”

Over the past 10 days, UPS has transported more than 4 million pounds of relief supplies for federal, state and private relief organizations responding to the devastation of Hurricane Katrina. The effort, with starting points ranging from California to Vermont, has involved both air and ground movements and focused primarily on the transportation of water, medicine, baby formula, non-perishable food items, emergency supplies and paper goods.

Beyond those items, UPS also has moved a mobile kitchen for the U.S. Park Police; a mobile hospital from Reno, Nev., to New Orleans, and child-sized cots from California to Dallas. The company now is arranging the move of a mobile water treatment system from Johannesburg, South Africa, to Gulfport, Miss.

Bushes Gone Fishin’

George I and George II - Gone Fishin'

(1) Talk about stumblin’ onto somethin’ special. This is the best stripe fishin’ anywhere in the Gulf. Who knew?!! (Cousin Jim)

(2) And a chicken shit in every pot! (Cousin Becky)

(3) “Kinda fishy how we handled Katrina, eh?” (Glennbo)

(4) The President (right) and his father, former President George H.W, Bush, photographed near the French Quarter. “Another sleasy photo op?” asked George Bush Senior, who is in the region with former President Bill Clinton to offer humanitarian aid. “Hell no! I swear to God that I thought W’s memo said we were going down to the French Quarter to fish for some STRIPPERS. I thought we’d be doing good. Damn kid never could spell .…” (Jana Jones)

Caption contest: Can you do better than the above captions? Sure you can. Leave your entry in the Comments section and we’ll promote the best of the best up to the main page.