Conservative Columnist: GOP Extortion Politics Is Based on the Assumption That Dems Will ‘Always, Always, Cave on Taxes’

Conservative New York Times columnist Ross Douthat:

This is the reality that liberals need to face: Much of the Republican “intransigence” and “hostage-taking” and “terrorism” that they deplore is a direct consequence of the fact that Republicans assume that Democrats will always, always, cave on taxes. And so long as that assumption keeps getting vindicated by events, there’s no incentive for the G.O.P. to accede to sweeping compromises on deficit reduction. Why would you compromise with a party that won’t actually fight for the revenues required to pay for the programs it claims to want to protect? Why would you sign off on tax increases that your notionally pro-government opposition doesn’t want to sign off on themselves? … In the long run, you can’t have compromise without intransigence.

Source: The Dish

The Line: Standard & Poor vs. the GOP ‘Ransoming’ U.S. Economy

  • Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell last week: “[The U.S. economy is] a hostage that’s worth ransoming.”
  • Greg Sargent at Washington Post: “Even if you agree with McConnell’s assessment — as I’m sure many conservatives do — it’s still a matter of fact that the embrace of the debt ceiling as a weapon for policy ends is a primary reason S & P downgraded the U.S. credit rating.”
  • Dave Weigel at Slate: S&P “opens fire on Republicans”
  • Megan McArdle at the Atlantic: “I will take a lot of hell for saying this, [but] I’m afraid I think that the lion’s share of the blame goes to the GOP, which escalated to this completely unnecessary showdown…”
  • Jonathan Chait at TNR: “[When] you have a political party that does not agree that revenue levels must bear a relationship to outlays, and is willing to foment a systemic crisis in order to maximize its leverage, you’re in trouble.”
  • Steve Benen at Washington Monthly: “When U.S. policymakers are using the possibility of voluntary default as a political weapon, those policymakers make the nation fundamentally less stable and less trustworthy.”

S&P Cites Tea Party’s Extortion Politics, Which It Calls ‘Political Brinkmanship,’ in Downgrading U.S. Credit Rating

In explaining why it was lowering the U.S. credit rating late on Friday, Standard & Poor’s singled out tea party obstructionism on the economy:

“The political brinkmanship of recent months highlights what we see as America’s governance and policymaking becoming less stable, less effective and less predictable than what we previously believed,” said S&P, one of three leading credit rating agencies.

“The statutory debt ceiling and the threat of default have become political bargaining chips in the debate over fiscal policy.”

“Brinkmanship” is putting it politely, of course. A better description is economic terrorism or political extortion.

It was the tea party, not the Democrats, who took the economy to the brink in the debt-ceiling negotiations, and yet, predictably, conventional wisdom in the Beltway has it that S&P was referring to everyone in Washington — that the hostage negotiators are just as bad as the hostage takers.

[…]

Tea Party’s Extortion Politics Is a Southern Tradition

In the U.S. House
In the U.S. House
The New America Foundation’s Michael Lind, a fifth generation Texan and a columnist at Salon, suggests that the corporate media has missed something important about the tea party movement: Its Southern character conservative political influence. This factor, says Lind, helps explains the movement’s reflexive impulse to engage in extortion politics:

From the earliest years of the American republic, white Southern conservatives when they have lost elections and found themselves in the political minority have sought to extort concession from national majorities by paralyzing or threatening to destroy the United States.

The Kentucky and Virginia Resolutions of 1798 and 1799 asserted the alleged right of states to “nullify” any federal law that state lawmakers considered unconstitutional. This obstructionist mentality led to the Nullification Crisis of 1832, when South Carolina refused to enforce federal tariffs. Civil War was averted only when President Andrew Jackson, a Southerner himself, forced the nullifiers to back down.

In 1820 and 1850 the South used the threat of secession to force the rest of the United States to appease it on the slavery issue. In 1861, the South tried to destroy the United States, rather than accept a legitimately elected president, Abraham Lincoln, whom it did not control.

[…]