CIA Violated Court Order When It Destroyed Torture Tapes

Michael Mukasey, George Bush’s new attorney general — same as the old attorney general — has yet to order federal employees to preserve evidence related to the CIA’s destruction of tapes of its torture sessions with terror suspects.

Even without Mukasey’s order, however, the CIA appears to have violated a court order in response to a lawsuit filed by the ACLU in 2004 to enforce a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request demanding information on the treatment and interrogation of prisoners:

The American Civil Liberties Union today filed a motion asking a federal judge to hold the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in contempt, charging that the agency flouted a court order when it destroyed at least two videotapes documenting the harsh interrogation of prisoners in its custody.

In response to Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests filed by the ACLU and other organizations in October 2003 and May 2004, the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York ordered the CIA to produce or identify all records pertaining to the treatment of detainees in its custody.

Despite the court’s ruling, the CIA never produced the tapes or even acknowledged their existence. Last week, in anticipation of media reports concerning the tapes, CIA Director Michael Hayden publicly acknowledged that the CIA had made the tapes in 2002 but destroyed them in 2005.

The ACLU brief and related legal documents are available online at: www.aclu.org/torturefoia.

Bush Vetoes Children’s Health Insurance Bill Again

No fanfare. George Bush vetoed this one in private:

President Bush vetoed legislation Wednesday that would have expanded government-provided health insurance for children, his second slap-down of a bipartisan effort in Congress to dramatically increase funding for the popular program.

It was Bush’s seventh veto in seven years – all but one coming since Democrats took control of Congress in January. Wednesday was the deadline for Bush to act or let the bill become law. The president also vetoed an earlier, similar bill expanding the health insurance program.

The Associated Press says that of the 43 million uninsured people nationwide, over 6 million are under the age of 18, which is almost 10 percent of all U.S. children.

Democrats plan to extend the current State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) program, as is, into next year and then force Bush to veto it again during the election campaign.

Huckabee and Wife Signed ’98 Ad Encouraging Women to ‘Graciously Submit’ to Husbands

In August 1998, Gov. Mike Huckabee and his wife Janet were among 131 signers of an advertisement opposing same sex marriage and in support of a resolution enacted by the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) earlier that year that erroneously suggested that prototypical 1950s-era “Ozzie and Harriet” style marriage and family life had its origins in the Bible:

‘Graciously submitting herself’ to her husband is a deceptively benign formulation for the status of women in biblical times.

“At a time when divorce is destroying the fabric of our society, you have taken a bold stand for the biblical principles of marriage and family life. We thank you for your courage,” the ad stated…

The SBC article describes marriage as “the uniting of one man and one woman in covenant commitment for a lifetime.” It also notes, “The husband and wife are of equal worth before God, since both are created in God’s image. A husband is to love his wife as Christ loved the church. A wife is to submit herself graciously to the servant leadership of her husband even as the church willingly submits to the headship of Christ.”

“Graciously submitting herself” to her husband is a deceptively benign formulation to describe the status of women in biblical times. In the Hebrew scriptures that form the basis of the Old Testament, for example, women were treated as harshly as they are treated today in conservative Islamic cultures:

  • Unmarried women were not allowed to leave the home of their father.
  • Married women were not allowed to leave the home of their husband.
  • They were normally restricted to roles of little or no authority.
  • They could not testify in court.
  • They could not appear in public venues.
  • They were not allowed to talk to strangers.
  • They had to be doubly veiled when they left their homes.

Polygamy was commonplace, and, of course, only men could have multiple spouses. Famous polygamists from the Bible included Abraham, Jacob, King David and especially Solomon, who had 700 wives and 300 concubines.

The Bible dictates that women take an inferior role in almost every aspect of life, according to a conservative biblical scholar:

[…]

Breaking: Libby Drops Appeal in CIA Leak Case – Could Set Stage for Christmas Pardon

USA Today:

Lewis “Scooter” Libby is dropping the appeal of his criminal conviction in the CIA leak case, his lawyer tells the Associated Press.

“We remain firmly convinced of Mr. Libby’s innocence,” attorney Theodore Wells tells the wire service. “However, the realities were, that after five years of government service by Mr. Libby and several years of defending against this case, the burden on Mr. Libby and his young family of continuing to pursue his complete vindication are too great to ask them to bear.”

President Bush commuted Libby’s 30-month prison sentence in July after a jury convicted him of lying to federal agents. They were investigating the source of leaks that identified an undercover CIA officer who was married to a former diplomat who had criticized the invasion of Iraq.

At her daily briefing today, White House spokesperson Dana Perino refused to speculate whether Scooter Libby would be pardoned over the upcoming holidays.

Wrong, Mitt: Religion Does Not ‘Require’ Freedom – Both Christianity and Judaism Flowered Under Repression

On KCRW’s “Left, Right and Center” political chat show last Friday, Tony Blankley, of all people — the former chief of staff for Newt Gingrich and editor of the Washington Times, the rightwing newspaper owned by cult leader Sun Yung Moon — joined Arianna Huffington and Matt Miller in tearing apart the speech on religion Mitt Romney delivered last week:

ARIANNA HUFFINGTON: There was also something else, which was the statement in the speech — the statement that freedom requires religion and religion requires freedom.

(Laughter among the co-hosts.)

MATT MILLER: What about Christianity and the Romans?

HUFFINGTON: You wonder, how was that allowed to stay for the final draft. I mean, what does it even mean?

TONY BLANKLEY: It was a wonderfully drafted phrase, even though it was historical nonsense.

HUFFINGTON: Historic nonsense and current nonsense. Also the fact that he mentioned the name, the word “Mormon” once compared to the number of times JFK mentioned [Catholicism] was a real indicator that he was still not entirely clear that this was not going to have some definite public relations disadvantages for him.

BLANKLEY: I’ve just got to say that Arianna picked on exactly the right phrase. It was such ahistoric nonsense. Not only does Christianity thrive under the repression of the Roman emperors but the whole history of Judaism — you know, this little religion has thrived over, what, 5,000 and a half years, and they have rarely ever experienced any freedom. The idea that you can’t — that religion has to exist only in freedom is just historic nonsense. It’s just silly.

Exception should be taken to Romney’s corollary statement that freedom requires religion, as well. At least three of our Founding Fathers — Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Paine — were irreligious, and there is ample evidence they understood freedom fairly well (leaving aside the very large matter of Jefferson’s dependence on slavery). In any case, they and others did not “require” religion in order to lay the groundwork for America’s experiment with personal liberty.

[…]

Source: Federal Prosecutor Says Some CIA Torture Videos Were Not Destroyed

Why Hasn’t Mukasey Called for Preservation of Evidence in Torture Video Scandal?

Within hours, if not minutes, after the CIA announced it destroyed two videos made in 2002 of its agents torturing al Qaida suspects, Attorney Gen. Michael Mukasey should have ordered the CIA and all federal agencies to preserve any evidence related to the filming of torture sessions involving terror suspects.

The silence and inaction on the preservation of evidence in this unfolding scandal by Bush’s new attorney general suggests what many suspected — that Michael Mukasey, like his predecessor Alberto Gonzales, is more concerned with the political preservation of his boss than he is the rule of law and the Constitution of the United States.

Over the weekend, the urgent need for this order was underscored by the development that other videos of other torture sessions may exist:

Prosecutor in trial of 9/11 conspirator Zacarias Moussaoui informs judges that he viewed two videos of al-Qaida suspects’ interrogations two months ago that government told court in 2003 it didn’t have — and CIA chief said were destroyed

A letter by a Virginia-based U.S. attorney to a federal appeals court appears to contradict CIA Director Michael Hayden’s public statements on the destruction of hundreds of hours of video footage of “extreme” interrogations of suspected al-Qaida operatives by strongly indicating that at least two of the videos still exist.

Charles Rosenberg, the U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia, wrote that his office viewed two videotapes of CIA interrogations of al-Qaida suspects as recently as September 19 and October 18 of this year — contrary to Hayden’s statement that the tapes were destroyed in 2005.

The CIA’s announcement that the videos had been destroyed, brought to mind the revelation by the White House last spring that as many as 5 million inter-office emails had been “lost.” It is likely that emails contained evidence that top Bush officials, including especially Karl Rove, engaged in a conspiracy to leak, and then cover up the leak, of the secret identity of Valerie Wilson, a CIA specialist in the black market for terror weapons.

Anyone who is familiar with the fundamentals of data storage can attest that it takes a concerted effort to “lose” data stored on hard drives. This is especially so for emails, which are stored on hard drives of both the sender and the receiver as well as on outgoing and incoming email servers.

The videos, like the emails, were presumably in digital format rather than old-fashioned videotape. If so, it is more than likely that multiple backup copies were created, which increases the chance that additional copies could still exist on a disk somewhere.

Of course, the CIA has had plenty of time to track down and obliterate backup copies of the torture videos, just as White House officials have had more than sufficient time now — eight months at least — to scour and wipe clean the hard drives on which the 5 million emails were stored.

This returns us to the main question: Where is Mukasey? His silence and inaction on the preservation of evidence in this unfolding scandal suggests what many suspected — that Michael Mukasey, like his predecessor Alberto Gonzales, is more concerned with the political preservation of his boss than he is the rule of law and the Constitution of the United States.

Video: Huckabee Claims God Is Driving Up His Poll Numbers

During a visit to Liberty University, Jerry Falwell’s “madrasa” in Virginia, a student asks “President” Huckabee what is behind his surge in the polls:

MIKE HUCKABEE: There’s only one explanation for it, and it’s not a human one. It’s the same power that helped the little boy with two fish and five loaves feed a crowd of 5,000 people. And that’s the only way our campaign could be doing what it’s doing. I’m not being facetious, nor am I trying to be trite. There literally are thousands of people across this country who are praying that a little will become much. And it has. And it defies all explanation. It has confounded the pundits, and I’m enjoying every minute of their trying to figure it out. And until they look at it from an experience just beyond human they’ll never figure it out. And that’s probably just as well.

That’s honestly why it’s happening.

GOP Initiative to Steal California Electoral College Votes Fails Again

The Republican Party’s effort to unilaterally award itself with 20 of California’s 55 Electoral College votes next year has failed to reach its fundraising goals for a second time:

Ballot initiatives tend to fail if California voters suspect the proposition has a hidden agenda.

A proposed initiative that drew national attention for its potential to affect next year’s presidential election will not appear on the June ballot, organizers said Thursday.

Republican backers of the measure, which could have tilted the presidential contest toward the GOP nominee by changing how California awards electoral votes, conceded that they were unable to raise sufficient funds.

Dave Gilliard, the manager of the current campaign, expressed bewilderment over the fact that more GOP fatcats did not pour money into the campaign.

“I was surprised that more people that finance these types of efforts didn’t step forward…We had strong supporters and good supporters but didn’t come anywhere close to making the budget,” Gilliard told the Los Angeles Times.

Gilliard’s “surprise” is itself surprising. GOP big money donors know, just as certainly Gilliard must know, that ballot initiatives tend to fail if California voters suspect the proposition has a hidden agenda.

The stated intent of Gilliard’s initiative was to make the California system “fair.” In fact, the real purpose was to give about 40 percent of the state’s Electoral College votes to the 2008 Republican nominee.

In October, a similar measure failed when the campaign manager discovered that its sole donation had been laundered through a front group to disguise the donor’s identity as a campaign chair and fundraiser for GOP presidential candidate Rudolph Giuliani.

White House Acknowledges Bush Lied about Iran Intel Yet Insists He Was Being ‘Truthful’

In Bushworld, you can have it both ways.

What little credibility Bush, and, by extension, the United States, had on Iran among our allies and other stakeholders in the Middle East has evaporated.

Wednesday night, George Bush’s spokesperson Dana Perino was forced to acknowledge in an email that Bush had been lying to the American people both about the status of Iran’s nuclear capabilities and about when he was informed that Iran’s nuclear program had been suspended.

Yesterday, however, when she asked if Bush was “candid” about what he knew and when he knew it, Perino answered, “Yes, he was.” Then, as proof of his candor, she launched into this tortured peroration:

If you look at the rest of that sentence, what the President — the President was clearly told that there was new information that was coming in, but he wasn’t told the details of it. And the President was also told that the intelligence community was going to need to go back and check out to find out if it’s true. What I said is that [Director of National Intelligence Mike] McConnell told the President, if the new information turns out to be true, what we thought we knew for sure is right: Iran does, in fact, have a covert nuclear weapons program, but it may be suspended. He said that there were many streams of information that were coming in that could be potentially in conflict. They didn’t have a lot of confidence in the information yet.

When challenged on the fact that her parsing did not square with what Bush actually said, Perino waved off the gap in credibility with this obviously scripted-in-advance bit of tripe:

I can see where you could see that the President could have been more precise in that language, but the President was being truthful.

The emphasis on “truthful” is hers. (And she will trot out the “he could have been more precise” nonsense twice more in the session.)

The White House press corps was refreshingly aggressive in putting Perino through her paces. As the session wore on, she sounded increasingly like her predecessor, Scott McClellan, in a skirt, deploying McClellan’s usual tricks — holding forth at length to answer a simple question and changing the subject whenever possible — in order to avoid producing a sound bite. On the other hand, she couldn’t entirely avoid that fact that Bush lied:

Q Dana, but listen to what he said: “He didn’t tell me what the information was; he did tell me it was going to take a while to analyze.” Was the President told that there was a possibility that Iran’s nuclear program could be suspended? That’s what you said he was told.

MS. PERINO: Yes, the President was told that there is new information [in August]…

Meanwhile, in the real world, no one — except increasingly desperate neo-cons and Bush-cult dead-enders — believes Perino, Bush or Cheney on this matter. What little credibility Bush, and, by extension, the United States, had on Iran among our allies and other stakeholders in the Middle East has evaporated. And rightly so, why should any foreign government put stock in anything the Bush administration has to say now?

Our only hope is that no serious world crisis erupts until the United States changes leadership in 13 months, and, presumably — hopefully — a normal president and administration take charge at long last.

A transcript of part of the discussion at the White House press briefing about Bush’s false statements on the Iranian intelligence follows:

[…]

Cheney Lied about Iranian Nuke Threat While Suppressing Intel That Iran Suspended Weapons Program in ’03

Repercussions continue to shake out in the wake of the release this week of a National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) that says Iran abandoned its nuclear weapons program four years ago.

At a news conference yesterday, George Bush denied knowing that U.S. intelligence had learned the Iranian program had been suspended when he warned the American people last month that Iran was on the verge of launching World War III. He was not lying, he suggested, but rather it was his own incompetence that led him to give the false warning. He said that when Director of National Intelligence (DNI) Mike McConnell told him in August that new information about the program had come to light, Bush did not bother to ask the DNI about the nature of the new developments.

If the muted response from reporters at the news conference to this assertion is a guide, journalists close to the White House believe that it while it is unacceptable for Bush to lie to them, it is perfectly okay for him to issue false predictions about an impending apocalypse if the warnings are based entirely on Bush’s ineptitude and lack of curiosity.

Today we learn that Dick Cheney has known about — and actively suppressed — the intelligence community’s finding for over a year. In particular, Cheney knew that Iran had suspended its weapons program in 2003 when he made this statement on Oct. 21, 2007, in an address to a Washington think tank:

Dismissing Iran’s claims that it is seeking only nuclear energy and not a weapons program, Cheney accused Iranian leaders of pursuing a practice of “delay and deception in an obvious effort to buy time.”

“Our country, and the entire international community, cannot stand by as a terror-supporting state fulfills its grandest ambitions … The Iranian regime needs to know that if it stays on its present course the international community is prepared to impose serious consequences.”

Yesterday, on CNN, New Yorker reporter Seymour Hersh reminded viewers that he’d reported on White House efforts to suppress the NIE last November:

HERSH: At the time, I wrote that there was a tremendous fight about it, because Cheney in the White House — the vice president did not want to hear this. So that there was a fight about that intelligence. And, actually, for the last year, I think the vice president’s office pretty much has kept — you know, the vice president has kept his foot on the neck of that report. That report was bottled up for a year.

The intelligence we learned about yesterday has been circulating inside this government at the highest levels for the last year — and probably longer.

The complete transcript of Hersh’s interview on CNN follows:

[…]