Politico.com Was Duped by Team Romney on Mitt’s Dad Marching with Martin Luther King

Nothing gets reporter Mike Allen hyperventilating like sticking it to the libs. Last week, Allen — former White House stenographer on the payroll of the Washington Post, now taking GOP dictation for Politico.com — reported a big gotcha on lefties who accused Mitt Romney of lying when he claimed he “saw” his father, the late liberal Republican governor of Michigan, George Romney, marching with Martin Luther King.

All of this evidence is important to present to the general public, but it is unnecessary for the Romney campaign — it has been clear for some time that they know perfectly well that the two men never marched together.

Allen “found” two eyewitnesses — probably with the help of the Romney campaign — who claim to remember seeing Gov. George Romney with King in Grosse Point, a wealthy enclave outside Detroit. One remembers the two men walking hand in hand:

“They were hand in hand,” recalled [Shirley] Basore, a former high-school English teacher. “They led the march. We all swung our hands, and they held their hands up above everybody else’s.”

She remembered the late governor as “extremely handsome.”

Another woman told Allen she remembers it vividly: “I was only 15 or 20 feet from where both of them were.”

It is possible that these two women saw Martin Luther King in Grosse Point in 1968, and they may have seen Gov. Romney at a civil rights march there in 1963. But, according to David Bernstein at the Phoenix, the historical record shows that the two men were never in Grosse Point — or anywhere else — at the same time:

Then-governor George Romney did indeed march in Grosse Pointe, on Saturday, June 29, 1963, but Martin Luther King Jr. was not there; he was in New Brunswick, New Jersey, addressing the closing session of the annual New Jersey AFL-CIO labor institute at Rutgers University.

Those facts are indisputable, and quite frankly, the campaign must have known the women’s story would eventually be debunked — few people’s every daily movement has been as closely tracked and documented as King’s. As I write this, I am looking at an article from page E8 of the June 30, 1963 Chicago Tribune, which discusses both events (among other civil-rights actions of the previous day), clearly placing the two men hundreds of miles apart. I also have here the June 30, 1963 San Antonio News, which carries a photo and article about Romney at the Grosse Pointe march; and an AP story about King’s speech in New Jersey.

A King researcher editing his letters from that time has stated definitively that the two men never marched together; Michigan and Grosse Pointe historians have stated definitively that King was not at the 1963 Grosse Pointe march; Michigan civil-rights participants of the time have concurred; so have those who worked for George Romney at the time.

The Romney team is, simply put, lying about this episode, Bernstein says:

All of this evidence is important to present to the general public, but it is unnecessary for the Romney campaign — it has been clear for some time that they know perfectly well that the two men never marched together.

Bear in mind that the Romney team has a substantial research team (and vast resources for outsourcing more). Bear in mind that the campaign has compiled vast documentation about the candidate’s father, particularly his civil-rights activities, long before the Phoenix posed the question earlier this week. Bear in mind that the campaign has direct access to George Romney’s materials and documents, his family members, his friends, his former staff, etc.

Believe me, they know the two men never marched together. This is an attempt to rewrite history. And even if it is a small rewriting, it is offensive.

Which brings us to a familiar question: Was Mike Allen complicit in the campaign’s deception, or was he simply lazy about checking the facts?

Mitt Romney has already had to backtrack on the claim that he actually saw his father with Martin Luther King. Mitt actually had the chutzpah to say that he was using a secondary definition of the verb “to see,” insisting that he “figuratively,” not literally, saw his father marching with Dr. King.

Politically, it’s a puzzle what Mitt hopes to gain from this. All this palaver about his support of civil rights for African-Americans might help him with his country-club base: folks who don’t approve of racism even though they don’t personally socialize with anyone who has brown skin. But the image of Mitt’s father marching with Martin Luther King will cost him votes among Christian nationalist voters, the GOP base whose reactionary views he insists he shares.

And telling easily debunked lies like this one will get Mitt Romney nowhere with both constituencies, who are used to the Bushies’ Teflon coated prevarications.

H/t: Blue Mass Group

Quote du Jour

It is perfectly possible to live a very moral life without a belief in God, and I think it’s perfectly possible to live a life peppered with ill-doing and believe in God.

— J.K. Rowling, British author of Harry Potter series

Rove’s Book Sold for Half of What He Expected – And Buyer Was Mary Matalin

Karl Rove put his book project up for auction among the big publishing houses in New York in mid-November. According to Crain’s New York Business on Dec. 17, a month passed with no offers:

It would be comforting to think the marquee imprints refused to do business with Rove because he betrayed a secret government operation tracking the black market for terror weapons.

The auction for Karl Rove’s memoir drags on a month after the Republican strategist made the rounds of publishers with Washington power lawyer Robert Barnett at his side.

“It’s very, very slow,” says an executive at one of the few houses left in the bidding. Early reports had predicted a $3 million sale, but some insiders are wondering if Mr. Barnett has had trouble getting to that number. He declined to comment.

On Friday, a deal was finally announced, but there’s an interesting twist — the buyer is Rove’s former White House colleague, conservative strategist Mary Matalin:

GOP strategist Karl Rove has agreed to write about his years as an adviser to President Bush in a deal worth over $1.5 million with former colleague Mary Matalin’s conservative imprint at Simon & Schuster, officials said Friday.

Rove … signed the deal with Threshold Editions, the imprint’s publisher and executive vice president Louise Burke said.

“All of us at Threshold are thrilled to publish the book from the man who had the president’s ear for two terms,” Burke said.

Rove’s agent, attorney Robert Barnett, said Threshold was chosen over eight other bidding publishers. Threshold didn’t say how much Rove would be paid, but the bidding reached at least $1.5 million, two publishing officials familiar with the bidding told The Associated Press. The official spoke on condition of anonymity, a standard industry practice.

On Nov. 21, not long after the auction had begun, Rove went on Charlie Rose’s show to promote the book, and made this outrageous claim:

ROVE: One of the untold stories about the war is why did the United States Congress, the United States Senate vote on the war resolution in the fall of 2002?

CHARLIE ROSE, HOST: Why?

ROVE: This administration was opposed to it. I‘m going to talk about that in my book … The administration was opposed to voting on it in the fall of 2002 … [because] we didn‘t think it belonged within the confines of the election. There was an election coming up in a matter of weeks. We thought it made it too political. We wanted it outside the confines of it. It seemed to make things move too fast. There were things that needed to be done to bring along allies and potential allies abroad.

It would be comforting to think that this ham-fisted, too easily refuted lie depressed the auction price of the book — or even better that book publishers refused to do business with a traitor who betrayed a secret CIA operation in 2003 that monitored the terror weapons black market.

It’s more likely the marquee publishing houses passed because sales projections looked weak — which gives reason for hope, too.

Is Hillary Clinton Inevitable — Genetically?

The Last Six Presidents Have Been Blue-Eyed
– But Will the Trend Continue in ’08?

Every president since Nixon — Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush, Clinton and Bush II — has had blue eyes. Why? One theory has it that our presidents’ eyes turned blue around the same time that color televisions became ubiquitous.

Among this years’ candidates, Hillary Clinton, John Edwards and Fred Thompson have blue eyes.

Thompson doesn’t have a chance. Edwards has no money. So…

H/t: VRW

McCain Surges in New Hampshire and Iowa

More signs that Republicans are giving a pass to Rudy and Mitt and reverting to the GOP primogenitor status quo, which means it may be John McCain’s turn, after all. In New Hampshire, where McCain beat George Bush by 20 points in 2000, American Research Group‘s tied with Romney:

Losing New Hampshire to McCain would be big blow for Romney, who was governor of neighboring Massachusetts.

McCain rebounded from a 25 percentage point deficit three weeks ago to tie Romney in American Research Group’s latest New Hampshire poll with 26 percent apiece. McCain also gained on Romney in a statewide Gallup Poll for USA Today, pulling within 7 percentage points of Romney. Romney led McCain 34 to 27 percent in that survey.

Losing New Hampshire to McCain would be big blow for Romney, who was governor of neighboring Massachusetts and so is familiar to the locals — whereas by a weird political calculus, all McCain has to do is come in second to “win” there.

In Iowa, McCain is running second to Huckabee, who has 28 percent support to McCain’s 20 percent. Romney is third with 17 percent, and Guiliani has 13 percent. (Eleven percent are still undecided.) McCain could “win” Iowa too if he comes in second.

McCain needs to come in second in South Carolina behind Huckabee, too, in order to winnow Romney out of the pack. But he’s in fourth place there now with 11 percent, according to a CBS poll released Thursday. Ahead of him are Huckabee with 28 percent, Romney 20 percent and Giuliani 12 percent.

Poll: Republican Approval of Bush’s Handling of the Economy Plummets

Republicans’ approval of Pres. Bush’s handling of the economy dropped 20 percentage points in the last month, according to American Research Group:

It suggests a wave of financial insecurity among Republican voters and could be a portentous sign of weakness inside Bush’s base.

45 percent of Republicans disapprove of the way George W. Bush is handling the economy. In November, 25 percent of Republicans disapproved of Bush’s handling of the economy.

That’s quite a drop in a key indicator. It suggests a wave of financial insecurity among Republican voters and could be a portentous sign of weakness inside Bush’s base.

Among all voters, 71 percent disapprove of Bush’s handling of the economy, while 28 percent approve.

Overall, 32 percent approved of Bush’s job performance versus 66 percent who disapproved.

Mukasey: Exposing Spies ‘Not a Risk Worth Taking’ – Except for Valerie Wilson?

I happened to catch the replay on C-SPAN this morning of Attorney Gen. Michael Mukasey’s address to the American Bar Association in which he laid out the case for granting immunity to giant telecom companies that allowed the Bush administration to spy on their customers.

“[The] specific identity of those who assist us with intelligence activities and the nature of their assistance must be protected as vital intelligence sources and methods. The risk of disclosing that kind of information is not a risk worth taking.”
– Mukasey

Despite the fact that my expectations for the speech and the new attorney general’s performance could not have been lower, both the content and delivery of the address were far worse than I could have imagined.

Mukasey read his speech like it was new material to him, like he’d been handed it in the limo that morning. His robotic performance brought to mind a hostage brought before cameras to read his ransom note — which prompts the question: What do the Bushies have on this man? Are they holding his family prisoners in Guantanamo? Are they threatening to shoot his dog? What other reason could there be for Mukasey to toss his reputation onto the crucible of the Bushies’ incompetence and corruption?

And then, three-quarters into his atonal droning, I found myself coming up off the couch when Mukasey made this outrageous assertion:

[The] specific identity of those who assist us with intelligence activities and the nature of their assistance must be protected as vital intelligence sources and methods. The risk of disclosing that kind of information is not a risk worth taking…

Seriously, did he look at the speech before he delivered it — or has Mukasey imbibed the Bushies’ Kool-Aid so deeply that he failed to grasp the tragic irony that, in 2003, his new masters blithely betrayed secret U.S. sources and methods — specifically a covert program that tracked blackmarket sales of terror weapons, in order to attack for political reasons the spouse of the covert agent in charge of the program, Valerie Plame Wilson?

Eventually, he raised the specter of the 9/11 attacks, of course, and suggested that the government needs American companies to fall in line in the phony war on terror, just like they did in the very real struggle against fascism in World War II. And then, finally, his odious, coulda-phoned-it-in reading aloud came to an end:

And of course, our efforts against that threat also must take place with scrupulous respect for civil liberties and within the rule of law. FISA modernization legislation is only one example of how we put in place a tool that we need to fight against terrorists, while protecting the rights of Americans. I recognize that as Attorney General I have to be committed to both of those goals. I am here to tell you that I am Thank you very much for inviting me today.

After those un-heartfelt words, he sat down — and like the true Bushie he has become, the attorney general refused to take questions from the audience.

GOP Senator: Trent Lott’s 2002 Pro-Segregationist Statement Was ‘Misconstrued’

The cluelessness of Republicans about their own racism never ceases to amaze. Remember back in 2002 when Sen. Trent Lott (R-Miss.) was caught on tape at a 100th birthday celebration for Sen. Strom Thurmond (R-S.C.), yearning for what life could have been if Thurmond had won the presidency in 1948 on a single-plank platform of preventing civil rights for African-Americans:

It was George Bush, not the wolfpack of the press, who forced Lott to stand down as Senate majority leader.

“I want to say this about my state: when Strom Thurmond ran for president, we voted for him. We’re proud of it. And if the rest of the country had followed our lead, we wouldn’t have had all these problems over all these years, either.”

Lott is leaving the Senate now to cash in as a high-priced lobbyist. During farewell speeches on the Senate floor Tuesday, Sen. Gordon Smith (R-Ore.) insisted that Lott’s pro-segregation statement misinterpreted:

[His] words were misconstrued, words which we had heard him utter many times in his big warm-heartedness trying to make one of our colleagues, Strom Thurmond, feel good at 100 years old. We knew what he meant. But the wolfpack of the press circled around him, sensed blood in the water, and the exigencies of politics caused a great injustice…”

Leaving aside the fact that Thurmond was barely sentient and thus unable to “feel good” at the time, it’s telling that Lott had “uttered” similar pro-segregation sentiments to his Republican colleagues “many times,” and that none of these GOP pols ever bothered to say, “Hey, Trent, your white sheet is showing.”

Of course, Sen. Smith is wrong about the source of Trent Lott’s troubles over his pro-segregationist remarks. It was George Bush, not the wolfpack of the press, who forced Lott to stand down as Senate majority leader.

Bush Lawyers – Including Alberto Gonzales – Discussed Destruction of CIA Torture Tapes

Current and former White House officials have admitted — though not for attribution — that senior Bush officials were deeply involved in discussions about whether to destroy videos of CIA agents torturing terror suspects:

This brings us back to an increasingly familiar question: What did Bush know about the destruction of the tapes, and when did he know it.

At least four top White House lawyers took part in discussions with the Central Intelligence Agency between 2003 and 2005 about whether to destroy videotapes showing the secret interrogations of two operatives from Al Qaeda, according to current and former administration and intelligence officials.

The accounts indicate that the involvement of White House officials in the discussions before the destruction of the tapes in November 2005 was more extensive than Bush administration officials have acknowledged.

Those who took part, the officials said, included Alberto R. Gonzales, who served as White House counsel until early 2005; David S. Addington, who was the counsel to Vice President Dick Cheney and is now his chief of staff; John B. Bellinger III, who until January 2005 was the senior lawyer at the National Security Council; and Harriet E. Miers, who succeeded Mr. Gonzales as White House counsel.

It was previously reported that some administration officials had advised against destroying the tapes, but the emerging picture of White House involvement is more complex. In interviews, several administration and intelligence officials provided conflicting accounts as to whether anyone at the White House expressed support for the idea that the tapes should be destroyed.

One former senior intelligence official with direct knowledge of the matter said there had been “vigorous sentiment” among some top White House officials to destroy the tapes. The former official did not specify which White House officials took this position, but he said that some believed in 2005 that any disclosure of the tapes could have been particularly damaging after revelations a year earlier of abuses at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq.

Some other officials assert that no one at the White House advocated destroying the tapes. Those officials acknowledged, however, that no White House lawyer gave a direct order to preserve the tapes or advised that destroying them would be illegal.

This brings us back to an increasingly familiar question: What did Bush know about the destruction of the tapes, and when did he know it.

Poll: Clinton Has Double Digit Lead in California – Huckabee Trails Giuliani by 8 Percentage Points

SurveyUSA via Pollster:

Giuliani is the most socially liberal Republican in the race so California is his to lose.

Among 741 likely Democratic primary voters in California asked to choose between three candidates, Sen. Hillary Clinton leads Sen. Barack Obama (49 percent to 30 percent) in a statewide primary, former Sen. John Edwards trails at 5 percent (conducted 12/14 through 12/16).

On the GOP side, Mike (“God Is My Campaign Manager”) Huckabee is doing surprisingly well in the land of secular hedonism:

Among 497 likely Republican primary voters in California asked to choose between five candidates, former Mayor Rudy Giuliani leads former Gov. Mike Huckabee (28 percent to 20 percent) in a statewide primary; former Gov. Mitt Romney trails at 16 percent, Sen. John McCain at 14 percent, former Sen. Fred Thompson at 13 percent (conducted 12/14 through 12/16).

Californians aren’t yet focused on the primary election on Feb. 5 — it’s the holidays and we’re used to having national primaries in the summer. Voters here will likely tune in after results from Iowa and New Hampshire show who’s got game. They will tend to dismiss the results in culturally dissonant South Carolina but will be keenly interested in who wins in Florida on Jan. 29

Giuliani is the most socially liberal Republican in the race so California is his to lose. Huckabee’s numbers in this poll are probably inflated from the combined factors of his positive headlines and the lack of serious focus by voters mentioned above. California Republicans tend to prefer secular fiscal conservatives (think Reagan and Schwarzenegger) so interest in Huckabee could fade as they learn more about his extremist religious views and record of raising taxes.

Even if Romney does well in January, it’s hard to see him gaining traction in California. The state has a sizable Mormon population that has been here since the Gold Rush in 1848 so it isn’t so much Romney’s religion that lacks appeal, it’s more about the fact that that Californians know a fake when they see one.

Giuliani’s principal threat next month could be McCain who has successfully rebuilt his campaign and received endorsements last week from key newspapers as well as the Republicans’ favorite former Democrat, Sen. Joe Lieberman.