Fox News Perpetuates McCain’s False Claim That He Supported GI Bill He Criticized As ‘Too Generous’ To Troops

Events in the campaign this week offer a case study in how Fox News assists the right wing — in this case, the McCain campaign — disseminate disinformation:

Monday: Speaking before the Veterans of Foreign Wars, John McCain falsely claimed credit for supporting the 21st Century GI Bill, which was sponsored by Sen. Jim Webb (D-Va.) and Sen. Chuck Hagel (R-Neb.):

As a political proposition, it would have much easier for me to have just signed on to what I considered flawed legislation. But the people of Arizona, and of all America, expect more from their representatives than that, and instead I sought a better bill. I’m proud to say that the result is a law that better serves our military, better serves military families, and better serves the interests of our country.

In reality, the bill McCain “sought” was not Webb-Hagel, which he opposed because its tuition benefits were “too generous” to the troops. The version he sought was a different bill that he co-sponsored:

The GI Bill as approved in no way resembles McCain’s so-called proportional proposal. The GI Bill provides 100 percent tuition payments to those who have served 36 months in active duty, and gives 80 percent to those who have served 24 months. By contrast, under McCain’s proposal, a soldier would have had to serve four times as long — 12 years in active duty – to be eligible for the most generous benefits.

If McCain’s version had passed, service members would have to wait to start college until they were 30 years old or older.

In the end, McCain did not even bother to show up on June 26 to vote on the bill, which passed the Senate 92 to six. All six senators who voted against it were Republicans. (The only other senator who did not vote was Ted Kennedy, who had recently been diagnosed with a brain tumor.)

But McCain may have been prevaricating to the wrong crowd. Turns out VFW leaders supported the Webb-Hagel bill:

VFW’s deputy director for legislative affairs Eric Hilleman: The Graham-Burr-McCain plan is “very partisan and is seen as a way to convolute the GI bill, or to slow the Webb-Hagel proposal down.”

VFW National Commander George Lisicki: “People are leaving after their first enlistment because they are tired of being shot at, and their families are tired of the frequent deployments … Whether they stay in four years or 20, we owe this newest, greatest generation the gift of education.”

Tuesday: Fox News runs with the story that McCain supported Webb-Hagel:

CAMERON: John McCain initially took some opposition to it [the GI Bill], because in McCain’s view, it didn’t proportionately give GI benefits to servicemen and women, depending on how long they were actually in active duty and service. He thought it should be a more proportionate award. He fought for it, it was inserted into the legislation, and in the end, McCain supported it.

In reality, the 12-year term was not “inserted in the legislation,” as Fox News asserted, and not only did McCain not “support” it, he didn’t even pause in his campaign long enough to vote for it “in the end.”

Either Fox did not bother to fact-check, or they were deliberately lying on McCain’s behalf.

Obama Responds to McCain at VFW Meeting

Yesterday, John McCain went before the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) and lied about Barack Obama’s record, saying that Obama voted to “legislate” failure by casting a single vote against troop funding because it did not contain a timetable, despite Obama’s having voted for funding the occupation every other time. McCain continued:
“One of the things that we have to change in this country is the idea that people can’t disagree without challenging each other’s character and patriotism.”
– Obama

“This was back when supporting America’s efforts in Iraq entailed serious political risk … It was a clarifying moment. It was a moment when political self-interest and the national interest parted ways.”

Today, speaking before the same group, Obama responded:

“Yesterday, Senator McCain came before you,” said Obama. “He is a man who has served this nation honorably, and he correctly stated that one of the chief criteria for the American people in this election is going to be who can exercise the best judgment as Commander in Chief. But instead of just offering policy answers, he turned to a typical laundry list of political attacks. He said that I have changed my position on Iraq when I have not. He said that I am for a path of “retreat and failure.” And he declared, “Behind all of these claims and positions by Senator Obama lies the ambition to be president” — suggesting, as he has so many times, that I put personal ambition before my country. That is John McCain’s prerogative. He can run that kind of campaign, and — frankly — that’s how political campaigns have been run in recent years. But I believe the American people are better than that. I believe that this defining moment demands something more of us.”

And:

[…]

Obama: ‘This Is Not Going To Be Easy’

Barack Obama in Albuquerque yesterday:

“We’ve got work to do,” said the senator. “This is not going to be easy. It would be nice, you would think, given how badly Bush and his folks have performed over the last eight years and considering the fact that John McCain has facilitated and worked with the Bush Administration on this disaster, you would like to think that folks would say, we don’t even have to run TV ads, you just open the papers and say ‘we gotta throw the bums out.'”

But, Obama added, “American politics is never that easy.” Telling the crowd in Albuquerque, New Mexico, that he was “confident” that the public would be persuaded by the need for change, the Illinois Democrat shifted focus to his Republican opponent.

“You know, Americans will put up with a lot of stuff,” he said. “We are not, contrary to what John McCain’s advisers will say, we are not a bunch of whiners. We will suck it up and work hard even when things are unfair. But what really gets us mad, what really motivates and activates us is when we start feeling like the rules are so tilted in favor of the special interest, lobbyists and fat cats; that our kids might not have better opportunities we had. And when we start feeling that, that’s when we know the American people rise up. That’s when we know change is going to come about.”

Cheating at Saddleback: McCain Appparently Knew Question About Supreme Court in Advance

MCCAIN: Could I — are we going to get back to the importance of Supreme Court Justices or should I mention —

WARREN: We will get to that.

MCCAIN: OK. All right. OK.

WARREN: You’re jumping ahead…

The McCain campaign is fighting hard against charges that McCain cheated on the rules of debate at a rightwing evangelical forum in a California megachurch over the weekend by cribbing the questions in advance. They are so desperate, apparently, that a McCain operative even played the POW card, citing McCain’s imprisonment by the Vietnamese 40 years ago as evidence somehow that he did not cheat Saturday night.
What’s suspicious here is that the topic of the Supreme Court had not come up in McCain’s interview, so it was not a topic to go “back” to.
Even “Pastor Rick” Warren, the multimillionaire evangelist who hosted the event — and who clearly favored McCain in the questioning — has admitted that McCain was not sequestered during the live session with Obama.

Warren told the live audience in the hall and on CNN that McCain was in a “cone of silence” to prevent him from having the advantage of hearing the questions in advance. In fact, McCain was in his car during much of Obama’s session, where he certainly could have listened to the interview.

And this exchange from the forum appears to indicate that McCain knew that Warren was going to ask him a very specific question about the Supreme Court. Notice how McCain asks if he can go “back” to a question about the court:

WARREN: Let’s deal with abortion. I, as a pastor, have to deal with this all the time, every different angle, every different pain, all of the decisions and all of that. Forty million abortions since Roe v. Wade. Some people, people who believe that life begins at conception, believe that’s a holocaust for many people. What point is a baby entitled to human rights?

MCCAIN: At the moment of conception. (APPLAUSE). I have a 25- year pro-life record in the Congress, in the Senate. And as president of the United States, I will be a pro-life president. And this presidency will have pro-life policies. That’s my commitment. That’s my commitment to you.

WARREN: OK, we don’t have to beleaguer on that one. Define marriage.

MCCAIN: A union — a union between man and woman, between one man and one woman. That’s my definition of marriage.

Could I — are we going to get back to the importance of Supreme Court Justices or should I mention —

WARREN: We will get to that.

MCCAIN: OK. All right. OK.

WARREN: You’re jumping ahead…

(CROSSTALK)

MCCAIN: When we speak of the issue of the rights to the unborn, we need to talk about judges. But, anyway, go ahead.

What’s suspicious here is that the topic of the Supreme Court had not come up in McCain’s interview, so it was not a topic to go “back” to. On the other hand, Obama had been asked a question about the Supreme Court during his earlier session, which McCain supposedly had not heard:

[…]

McCain Cites POW Status in Denying He Cheated at Evangelical Forum

Did John McCain cheat by cribbing questions in advance at the rightwing megachurch forum Saturday night?
UPDATE


McCain operative Nicole Wallace vehemently denied claims that McCain heard Barack Obama being questioned, even though McCain was not sequestered in a “cone of silence,” as Rick Warren, the multimillionaire evangelist and moderator of the forum, had asserted to the live audience.

What’s bizarre here is that Wallace cited McCain’s status as POW 40 years ago as evidence that he did not cheat Saturday night:

“The insinuation from the Obama campaign that John McCain, a former prisoner of war, cheated is outrageous,” Ms. Wallace said. [Emphasis added.]

Here’s how Warren described the “rules” he established for the forum in his introductory remarks to the audience Saturday night:

RICK WARREN, PASTOR, SADDLEBACK CHURCH: Now, what I decided is to allow for proper comparison, I’m going to ask identical questions to each of these candidates. So you can compare apples to apples. Now, Senator Obama is going to go first. We flipped a coin, and we have safely placed Senator McCain in a cone of silence.

During his session, Obama gave what post-game analysts have called “thoughtful” and “nuanced” answers, which is a coded way to say he overthought the questions and his answers were too wordy.

However, when it was McCain’s turn, he gave very short answers — you know, like bumperstickers — and often interrupted Warren to start answering before the question was complete.

Was McCain in the “cone of silence” while Obama was questioned? According to Rick Warren, in an interview on CNN on Sunday, he was not:

[…]

Limbaugh: Edwards Sought ‘Woman Whose Mouth Did Something Other Than Talk’

Sometimes what comes out of the rightwing is so outrageous and disgusting that even their enemies feel something akin to embarrassment for them. When I first heard the audio of Rush Limbaugh’s latest and maybe vilest smear yet, I was too repulsed to write about it. But this one needs to be aired, in the sense of “vented.”
“Rush Limbaugh is a hole.”
– Keith Olbermann

Keith Olbermann covered the story on MSNBC’s “Countdown” on Tuesday. See video above, and here is a transcript of the highlights:

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

RUSH LIMBAUGH, RADIO TALK SHOW HOST: We‘ve been told that Elizabeth Edwards is smarter than John Edwards. That‘s part of the puff pieces on them that we‘ve seen. Ergo, if Elizabeth Edwards is smarter than John Edwards, is it likely that she thinks she knows better than he does what his speeches ought to contain? And what kind of things he ought to be doing strategy wise in a campaign? If she is smarter than he is, could it have been her decision to keep going with the campaign?

In other words, could it be that she doesn‘t shut up? Now, that‘s as far as I‘m going to go.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

OLBERMANN: Actually, it wasn‘t. Never is. A minute later—

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

LIMBAUGH: It just seems to me that Edwards might be attracted to a woman whose mouth did something other than talk.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

[…]

World-Class Hypocrisy: U.S. Media Ignores Bush’s Actions in Iraq As He Criticizes Russia’s Invasion of Georgia



One of the most dire repercussions of George Bush’s misbegotten invasion of Iraq in 2003 is that it has undermined U.S. credibility in speaking out against Russia’s invasion of Georgia today. Of course, having no credibility has never stopped Bush and his aides from speaking out, and it is not stopping them now.
The only criticism from the American media leveled at Bush for his hypocrisy in criticizing Russia’s invasion of a sovereign nation has come from Jon Stewart’s comedy news show.
At a meeting of the United Nations Security Council this week, the brazen hypocrisy of the Bush administration’s mindset was put on full display. First, U.N. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad accused Russia of trying to topple the leader of Georgia, Mikhail Saakashvili — to which Russia’s U.N. ambassador, Vitaly Chuckin, responded in a news conference after the meeting, “‘Regime change’ is purely an American invention.”

At the news conference, Khalilzad dug the hole of U.S. hypocrisy even deeper: “We want to make sure our Russian colleagues understand, ” he told reporters later, “that the days of overthrowing leaders by military means in Europe — those days are gone.” (The emphasis was Khalilzad’s.)

As comedian Jon Stewart pointed out, “It’s amazing how adding the phrase ‘in Europe’ makes our actions [in Iraq] more palatable.”

Of course, Bush and his associates have been accused of far worse things than hypocrisy — including war crimes, lying to Congress and criminal neglect while an American city drowned, just for starters — and they have yet to be held accountable or suffer any repercussions.

Luckily for them, however — except for Stewart on his comedy news show — there hasn’t been any criticism in the American corporate media of these and other outrageous pronouncements by Bush and his senior foreign policy officials.

Poll: Obama Wins Bobblehead Election By 10 Points

National polls are mostly meaningless for the next few weeks, but this one may be surprisingly noteworthy:

Barack Obama has been declared winner of the 2008 bobble head election, held by sports consulting firm The Goldklang Group in six minor league baseball stadiums this month.

Obama defeated John McCain 55 percent to 45 percent, as minor league fans cast ballots at voting booths inside the six stadiums. Each fan received a bobblehead doll of his/her candidate. Voting stopped and a winner was proclaimed when one candidate’s bobblehead supply ran out.

It sounds silly, as anything involving bobble heads does, but there are a couple of factors here to consider. First, the demographics of fans of minor league baseball are much closer to NASCAR dads and Sam’s Club shoppers than, say, aficionados of chardonnay and arugula, which bodes well for Barack Obama, whom Republicans are trying to brand as uppity, oops, sorry, elitist, because his base includes educated, upper-income wine drinkers who prefer salad made with greens that are more flavorful than iceberg.

In addition, Obama swept McCain at ball games even in generally Republican areas like South Carolina, Florida and South Dakota, as well as in the Democratic strongholds of Massachusetts and New York. In St. Paul, Minn., site of the Republican National Convention next month, Obama trounced McCain by 58 percent to 42 percent.

Another factor to consider is that, in August 2004, the same bobblehead poll accurately predicted the George Bush would narrowly defeat John Kerry.

Of course, there’s one factor that may undermine the accuracy of the poll: It’s unclear how many of the bobblehead voters are under the age of 18 and thus ineligible to vote in the real election in November.